The Special Tax Loss Harvesting Opportunity for 2022

There is a tax loss harvesting opportunity in 2022 that has not existed in recent years to the scope and scale it exists today: tax loss harvesting with bonds and bond funds. In most recent years, many bonds and bond funds have not had significant built-in-losses. 2022 is different: now there are plenty of bonds and bond funds in taxable accounts with significant built-in-losses. 

Tax Basketing for Bonds and Bond Funds

Bonds tend to be tax inefficient, for two reasons. First, they generate ordinary income, which is taxed at the taxpayer’s highest marginal tax rate. Second, they tend to have higher yields than equity investments. Thus, a dollar of a bond fund often produces more taxable income than a dollar of an equity fund, if they are both owned inside a taxable account.

As a result, holding bonds and bond funds in traditional retirement accounts is often logical from a tax basketing (or tax location) perspective. If they produce ordinary income anyways, why not hold them in a traditional retirement account (IRA, 401(k), etc.) where the owner can defer the timing of the ordinary income taxable event (through later Roth conversions and/or distributions)? 

Tax Basketing for Stocks and Equity Funds

Bonds also don’t suffer from the “transmutation” problem equities have. Stocks and equity funds, in most cases, pay “qualified dividend income” which qualifies for the lower long term capital gains tax rates (including the 0% long term capital gains tax rate). Holding them in a traditional retirement account transmutes that preferred income into ordinary income, subject to the taxpayer’s marginal ordinary tax rate. 

Now, as a practical matter, most Americans have most of their non-real estate financial wealth in traditional retirement accounts. Having some equities in traditional retirement accounts should not in any way cause despair. But, on the margins, it can be beneficial to review the overall portfolio to see if there can be some tax efficiency gains made by some tax rebasketing of assets. 

Rebasketing and Tax Loss Harvesting

The deadline for tax loss harvesting for 2022 is December 31, 2022. 

To my mind, some of the best 2022 tax loss harvesting will be selling bonds and bond funds at a loss in taxable accounts. Why is that? Because this sort of tax loss harvesting enjoys the main benefits of tax loss harvesting and it can achieve a great tax basketing result. 

Bonds create ordinary income and are generally higher yielding than equities, which often produce tax favored qualified dividend income. Thus, from a tax basketing or tax location perspective, it can often make sense to hold bonds and bond funds in a traditional retirement account and hold equities in a taxable account. Today, many investors can do some tax loss harvesting and strategically reconfigure their portfolios to make them much more tax efficient. Here is an example of how this could play out.

Jorge is 30 years old. He currently owns a diversified equity fund (Fund A) inside his workplace traditional 401(k) plan worth $80,000. It has a 2% annual dividend yield, most of which is qualified dividend income (though of course it is tax deferred inside the 401(k) and will later be subject to ordinary income tax when withdrawn or Roth converted). Separately, he owns a diversified bond fund (Fund B) inside his taxable brokerage account. It is worth $20,000, and Jorge has a $24,000 tax basis in the fund. The bond fund has a 3% annual interest yield ($600), all of which is ordinary income. Jorge wants to have an 80% / 20% equity to bond allocation. 

Here’s Jorge’s portfolio today:

AssetAmountAnnual Taxable Income
401(k) Fund A (Equity)$80,000None
Taxable Fund B (Bond)$20,000$600
Total$100,000$600

Jorge, could, in theory, execute two transactions to both tax loss harvest and become more tax efficient from a tax basketing perspective. First, Jorge could exchange his $20K of Fund B for $20K of an equity fund inside his brokerage account with a dividend yield similar to Fund A. Second, inside his 401(k), he could exchange $20K worth of his Fund A holding for a bond fund with an income yield similar to Fund B. If Jorge’s new fund inside the 401(k) is not substantially identical to Fund B, he can claim most, if not all, of the $4,000 loss, though the prior month’s Fund B dividend might slightly reduce the loss under the wash sale rule.

Here’s Jorge’s portfolio after these two transactions:

AssetAmountAnnual Taxable Income
401(k) Fund A (Equity)$60,000None
401(k) Bond Fund$20,000None
Taxable Equity Fund$20,000$400
Total$100,000$400

Jorge may obtain two tax benefits from these transactions. First, assuming he successfully navigates the wash sale rule, he may be able to deduct up to $3,000 against ordinary income by triggering the capital loss on the Fund B sale. 

Second, regardless of whether he successfully navigated the wash sale rule, he has just made his portfolio more tax efficient. It used to be that he reported $600 of ordinary income (from Fund B) on his tax return. Now that sort of interest income is hidden inside the 401(k). If he now receives approximately $400 a year in qualified dividend income from the new equity fund inside the taxable brokerage account, he has (i) reduced his annual taxable income by $200 (and growing through compounding) and (ii) now has mostly qualified dividend income from the taxable account instead of ordinary income, lowering his federal tax rate on his portfolio income. He has done all that without disturbing his overall asset allocation. 

Getting the tax basketing of his investments better without changing his investment allocation is likely to be worth it even if loses the tax loss due to the wash sale rule. He would want to review the options available to him inside his 401(k) to see if there is an acceptable (to him) bond fund that is not “substantially identical” to Fund B so as to avoid the wash sale rule being triggered by the investment in a bond fund inside the 401(k). 

Conclusion

Declines in the stock and bond market are some of the lemons of 2022. But, there’s a chance to make some lemonade. When it comes to bonds held in taxable accounts, there may be an opportunity to obtain two benefits: tax loss harvesting and better tax basketing. 

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on Twitter at @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, legal, investment, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

One comment

Comments are closed.