Problems with Annuities

If you listen to personal finance podcasts in Fall of 2026, you know annuities are having their moment in the sun.

I believe that prior to considering an annuity, one must consider seven problems presented by that path.

When assessing annuities, it is valuable to consider them against their lowest cost, least restrictive, and most readily available alternative. That alternative, to my mind, is the index fund.

Below is simply one commentator’s (Sean Mullaney’s) opinion. It is not in any way investment, tax, or legal advice for you or anyone else.

Assets Become Income Very Efficiently

Index funds, whether in a taxable brokerage account, Roth retirement account, or traditional retirement account, become income very efficiently in retirement. Whenever a retiree needs a specific amount of money to fund living expenses, he or she can sell a specific amount of the fund. With index funds, there is rarely much of a “back-end” expense such as a load. Money from an index mutual fund redemption or money from an index fund ETF sale can get into a retiree’s checking account very quickly.

The process tends to be quick, simple, and easy. Retirees control the dates they get the money, the amount received each time, etc. Very efficient and very flexible. In today’s world, expenses of holding index funds are quite small. Lastly, the tax treatment of index funds tends to be favorable when compared to that of annuities, as discussed below.

Compare the all around efficiency of index funds with the friction caused by annuities. Finding and vetting a provider. Annuity fees. An inflexible distribution schedule. Surrender charges on exit.

If index funds become income in retirement efficiently, and annuities have inefficiencies, why partner with an insurance company to help fund retirement?

Why do we fear creating a “paycheck” with index funds when doing so in retirement tends to be taxed less than our W-2 paychecks?

Many Americans Already Have a Large Annuity

Imagine I work for Best Buy. I walk into your living room and notice the 97 inch television mounted on the wall.

The first words out of my mouth are “You know what this living room needs? Another 97 inch big screen TV!”

You would think I was crazy, wouldn’t you?

Those advocating for annuities for many American retirees miss a big issue: most Americans already have a very significant annuity: Social Security!

Affluent Americans can have annual Social Security benefits in excess of $40,000 or $50,000 a year per retiree. That is an annuity from a rather creditworthy creditor, the federal government.

If a married couple has over $80,000 a year coming in from Social Security, why do they need an additional annuity from an insurance company?

Spending Studies Justifying Annuities

Commentators defend annuities by arguing that studies show those with annuities spend more in retirement. For example, listen to Jean Chatzky at around the 12 minute mark of this podcast.

Have you or I validated those studies? I certainly have not, and you most likely have not.

But let’s go with them for a moment. Let’s assume the studies are valid just for the sake of argument.

If you are reading my blog, the odds are high that you are (A) a Boglehead, (B) a member of the FI community, or (C) someone who believes you manage your financial affairs better than the average American does. It is exceedingly odd for those who fall into those categories to guide their behavior based on how others behave. The whole point of being A, B, and/or C is you conduct your financial affairs differently than most people.

The studies are studies of hundreds or thousands of retirees who are not you. Why are you interested in the spending behavior of people who are not you?

Nolan Ryan didn’t decide how to pitch to hitters based on what minor league pitchers did. Why would anyone who perceives themselves to be different from the crowd make investment decisions based on the crowd’s tendencies?

Retirees flocking to annuities based on studies risk making an investment decision based not on their own circumstances but rather based on the behavior of others.

Taxes

The tax treatment of using index funds to fund retirement tends to be favorable. That’s true regardless of whether the index funds are in taxable accounts, Roth retirement accounts, or traditional retirement accounts.

By contrast, annuities create inflexible ordinary income in taxable accounts based on an exclusion ratio calculation. Especially when compared to capital gains income, annuity income from a taxable annuity is quite inefficient and inflexible.

Flexibility

Why should retirees spend in retirement based on an insurance company’s payout schedule?

Legendary New York sports talk radio host Joe Benigno preaches that in professional sports, “the greatest ability is availability.”

In personal finance, the greatest ability is flexability. Please pardon the misspelling 😉

In all seriousness, do we expect our annual spending in retirement to be a flat line? I anticipate in my retirement some years my wife and I will take a 15 day vacation in Wailea, and we might even fly Premium Economy to get there. Other years it will be a short drive up to Santa Barbara for a 5 night stay at a Fairfield Inn by Marriott paid for with Bonvoy points.

Some years in retirement have payments for kids’ weddings, new roofs, and new cars. Other years are less costly and retirees go to a single Dodgers game and a Gary Gulman show.

Why shouldn’t our income be flexible in retirement when our expenses are likely to fluctuate?

Single Party Creditor Risk

Index funds have an advantage over annuities.

Index funds do not require signing up to assume single party creditor risk in retirement.

Buying an annuity makes a retiree the creditor of an insurance company. This paper by Thomas E. Lambert and Christopher B. Tobe explores the downsides of this arrangement.

We hear the term “guaranteed income” when talking about annuities. Is it really guaranteed? There is no Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation when it comes to annuities. Annuities are subject to a patch work of 50 state regulators. Do we think insurance companies run to the states requiring the most in terms of protecting annuitants? Probably not.

You might say “retirees using index funds may be subject to their own single party creditor risk by using broad domestic bond index funds.” Yes, it is true the majority of holdings in domestic bond index funds tends to be debt issued by a single party. However, that single party is not an insurance company. Rather, it is the United States government.

Regardless of one’s views of the United States government, two things are true. First, the government can print its own money. Second, the government can impose taxes. These are two powers making bond default highly unlikely. At a minimum, the United States government can fund its debt repayments in ways insurance companies can only dream of.

Remember Jack Bogle?

The older I get (Pushin’ 50 as of the publication of this blog post), the more I admire Jack Bogle for inventing the retail index fund in the 1970s. Bogle pushed back hard on the industry that made him wealthy.

Jack Bogle was right and they were wrong!

Jack’s idea helped pave the way for millions to successfully retire. Pairing index funds with stable Social Security income set up the perfect “1-2 punch” for millions of Americans to retire.

Why is now the time to abandon or at least limit that approach?

Boiled down, to the extent a retiree chooses an annuity over the lowest-cost, least restrictive, readily available alternative, the index fund, they are choosing an insurance company for retirement over the wisdom Jack Bogle.

That does not strike me as a great trade off.

Conclusion

This post demonstrates why I am so fond of index funds and why I question the use of annuities in funding retirement.

Due to the wisdom of Jack Bogle, we live in the golden age of holding low cost, well diversified investments in retirement. Index funds give us the one free lunch in investing, diversification.

I believe we should think twice (or more) before sacrificing a part of that free lunch in order to work with an insurance company for retirement income planning.

Will some retirees enjoy financial success with annuities? Of course. This post is not gloom-and-doom. Rather, it states my views about annuities and how they compare to index funds in America as of 2026.

Of course, this post is simply my opinion. It is in no way investment, tax, or legal advice for you or anyone else.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on LinkedIn: @SeanWMullaney

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

24 comments

  1. I’m with you on all of this, as long as we are speaking about index-linked annuities, which are a type of security investment and basically an apples to apples comparison to index funds.

    When we bring in immediate-income annuities, it’s a different set of criteria (in my opinion), since they are insurance products and a better fit for nervous investors who want security of having their basic expenses covered by a guaranteed income stream versus leaving retirement funds invested in index funds. A lot of the trade offs are the same, but the psychology (& fees!) are different.

    The clients who are a best fit for immediate income annuities are those who desire a guaranteed supplement to SS to cover basic living expenses, leaving assets invested in index funds for discretionary expenses in retirement. Less likely to fit the profile of a typical reader here, but that’s the space I am ok with immediate income annuities.

    QLACs have their spot too, more as a longevity risk offset for folks who don’t care about leaving an inheritance. Again, my opinion, not advice!

    But index-linked annuities? Typically a bad deal when the alternative is a simple index fund portfolio; I share your opinion there.

    1. Index annuities are, IMHO as a personal investor, undiluted poison. For starters, they don’t include dividends that tan equivalent index fund pays: dividends have contributed as high as 20% of the compounded returns of the S&P500. Add to this, caps, participation rate discretion by the issuer, etc.

  2. I’m always suspicious of folks who take such a black and white stance on a subject, especially financial planning. Annuities are another tool that can effectively be used to fund retirement. My wife is 13 years younger than me, so the annuity will kick in when I’m 67, currently 63. It’s a fixed rate deferred annuity. My ss will be approximately $4400 a month, annuity $2300 for both our lives with a 20 year guarantee. Fidelity has a good offering of highly rated fixed rate annuities with reasonable fees.

    The other 2/3 of our funds are in index funds, a covered call fund, gpix and money market fund, along with $1.3mm in equity in our home.

    I’ve watched our safe index funds fall 40% , so diversification wins, alternative streams of income.

  3. Index annuities do not pay dividends and will have a lower return. The promised lock is only available one day a year, and you are then forced into a 3% rate of return. They often have an income cap, so if you buy at the end of a downturn, you could be missing out on some growth. For a 6 year myga that you expect a 10% average rate of return (60% total), 10% loss protection is highly unlikely to be beneficial.

    MYGA annuities (somewhat like CDs) can pay up to 6.3% while tips and ibonds have a current nominal rate of 5% and high yield savings is a tad over 3.5% Shopping around is critical as some mygas pay less than savings rates and are terrible. Corporate bonds fall when stocks do, so they aren’t a good counter balance.
    When used as a ladder to fund the next 3-5 year’s budget, MYGAs can be an effective tool to de-risk. The biggest negative is they don’t hedge against high inflation. They certainly have the risk of early withdrawal penalties, so no emergency funds should ever be invested in them. Perhaps having a mix of MYGAs and shorter term TIPS to cover the first of a two bucket strategy is nolt a bad idea. I plan on not repleneshing the short term bucket during downturns, waiting for recovery. This is more stressful and not for everyone. It also takes more effort as you generally have to buy an annuity each year, and the takes more effort than buying a tips fund (perhaps equal to buying an individual tips bond). The emotions of the decision are the hard part.

  4. I’ve gradually moved in my opinion from ALL retail annuities are garbage to SPIA/DIA can be a reasonable choice for the right reasons and the right person.

    I mostly channel Prof. Wade Pfau, who convinced me that a SPIA maximizes lifetime income. But the reader has to understand the trade-off: Money is not expected to be left after death. For those who care about an inheritance, the SPIA can be the sequence of returns risk mitigation supplement after other fixed income is considered in lieu of a TIPS or a bond allocation.

    So long as the retirement planner (DIY or not) understands that they are building the SORR part of the plan, I’m fine with one person choosing a TIPS ladder, another choosing a Bond allocation, and a third a supplemental SPIA. I suspect the TIPS ladder makes the most cents, particularly nowadays, but more important than the small difference in financial outcome is the ability of the DIYr to stay the course when markets crash. For that they have to pick the SORR mitigation that matches their personality and context.

    That is Pfau’s brilliant contribution to retirement planning by the way: pick a plan the investor will stick with. And perhaps most important of all, what the surviving spouse will stick with. I chose delayed SS as our annuity, but if it required a supplement I would buy a retail SPIA simply because my wife spaces out at the mention of TIPS. 😉

  5. Longevity risk protection. That’s the primary function of immediate annuities. No index fund can do that with any strategy you can cook up. Without pooling of mortality risk, index funds alone cannot fully replace immediate annuities. I agree with the cons that you raise about annuities, but a balanced comparison needs to emphasize longevity risk protection. You also don’t discuss sequence of return risk associated with investments. Immediate annuities are not subject to this risk, not to be treated lightly.

    1. Agreed. The writer completely ignored the biggest benefit to the good annuities (SPLA/DIA/QLAC), which is mortality credits. To ignore this and focus on index annuities, which agreed are poor total money decisions, misses almost all of the point and is a huge, glaring mistake that dumps this entire article into the trash heap. Ignoring the safety provided to mitigate SoRR is another huge oversight. A simple search would have highlighted both of these benefits, so perhaps the writer is incentivized to be so overtly biased against annuities.

      Agreed index annuities are a recent insurance product/scam to transfer risk with money. There are better and cheaper ways to do this, but people often pay for convenience.

      I expect he also missed the point about the studies with those having annuities, because longevity derisking grounds that entire benefit.

      1. You seem to misunderstand my article. My article is in no way limited to an analysis of index annuities. Further, my article is very clearly titled Problems with Annuities. I think it’s fair to say I presented problems with annuities.

        Previously, I’ve written on my blog about sequence of return risk. I’m not too concerned about it for diversified index investors.

  6. I thought the same way when I was 50. Now that Im 70 and I retired, I think differently. 1. Assets become income very efficiently-sure they do, but the issue is we don’t want to sell ourselves or tie ourselves in knots deciding what to sell and when. We just want a paycheck without having to think about it. A lot of us automated contributions and now we want to automate distributions. Keeps things simple 2. Some of us having spending wants and needs beyond what SS (and even some pensions) deliver. That’s certainly our situation (and both of delayed SS, myself to 70.) 3. We bought QLACs-this provides some mitigation for longevity risk, cognitive decline, and loss of spousal SS. It also provides increase flexibility and license to spend in the Go-Go years because the latter portion of life is more secure. 4. The distribution will satisfy part of RMDs which would have been taxed in any case. 5. We bought from 2 different A++ companies limiting the credit risk exposure. 6. We are Bogleheads too and long-time Vanguardians. The majority of our investments are there in simple index funds. The QLACs are just a portion of our income. This needn’t be an all or nothing commitment.

    1. Thanks for commenting. I don’t see any reason to tie oneself in knots over selling some index funds to fund retirement expenses. In my opinion, it’s a rather simple exercise.

  7. I totally agree with your conclusions on annuities, even on straightforward annuities like MYGAs one can get burned. Case in point take Banker Life Insurance, I bought an annuity in 2017 at 3.75% for 5 years which was an awesome rate at the time when banks were paying .90 to 1.00% only to find out Greg Lindberg, the CEO, was attempting to bribe Insurance Commissioners and siphoning money for his personal Yachts and Palaces. Bottom line I ended up getting my money back from the State Insurance Dept. after 3 years of litigation and earning 1% on the investment after it matured and was held until litigation was finalized. Lesson Learned! BTW, only annuity I believe in is the QCD – CGA since I’m giving money to Charity anyway and I’m over 70 1/2 years old!

  8. I am a healthy, unmarried, childless female with one older sibling with health issues. I retired at 58 in 2018, and wanted secure income until Soc Security at 67 yo AND the financial resources to help my sibling.
    At 48, I invested an unexpected inheritance in two lifetime annuities, in two different companies, one S&P 500 linked (index linked) and one Fixed Rate and both having 11 yr wait periods to start.
    This was an “experiment” for me to see which annuity type did better over time: fixed rate or variable rate. (Through the period of 2008-2026, the variable rate annuity has won, and it has a higher remaining inheritable balance now than the fixed rate). Is it anywhere near what equal dollar amounts in my ROTH is? No, but that’s NOT THE POINT. It was a safe and reliable income source, than could be depended upon with NO FURTHER EFFORT.

    I also felt great about buying a 20 yr SPIA (single premium immediate annuity) in Dec 2022 beause:
    – interest rates were high (7.5%) which bumped the SPIA payment. Internal rate of return about 6-7%. The Immediate Annuity had no up front or back-end charges. Is it going to keep up with inflation? No! But my Social Security, Brokerage, ROTH and IRA WILL.
    I’m ok with one of 5 streams of income (Annuities, Soc Security, ROTH, IRA, BRKG) not keeping up. Because I value the security of a monthly base payment it gives me. I can forget about worrying about covering the basic costs of life.

    – At retirement, I could use the profit from selling a house in 2018 (high prices then) to supplement my annuity income that I started 4 yrs after retirement. I downsized to a much cheaper home in a rural area, and house sale proceeds $ would last until Soc Sec started at 67 yo.
    – peace of mind about giving myself enough time and a steady paycheck to learn how to create a retirement income in the years before starting social security at 67 yo, when I would need to have a retirement income plan in place that would work for the rest of my life.

    My conclusion: I’ve been extraordinarily glad I did my fixed, variable and SPIA annuities, as I worry MUCH less about income than my peers. Annuities have a place, especially for single. childless (no automatic caretaker) people who need a level of certainty of income that you can’t get from reliance on markets alone.
    Caveat: you MUST buy from a reputable annuity company with a Loooong track record, you MUST read the small print and you MUST understand what it’s costing you for the Annuities.
    Then: fugeddaboutit!! and go live life 🙂
    THAT’S what annuities are for.

    1. Your take on the role of annuities as a reasonable sleep-well-at-night tool is correct, and your explanation highlights the importance of avoiding a binary approach to annuities as all good or all bad. They have their shortcomings and the annuity buyer has a duty to understand all of those shortcomings. If the buyer acknowledges those shortcomings with eyes wide open and they decide that the positive aspects outweigh the negatives for their situation, then buying one can be completely rational.

  9. Pensions (or SPIAs) are a wonderful compliment to a high net worth household if the combination of Social Security and a Pension (or SPIA) covers one baseline expenditure. My wife and I SS is $90K a year and my pension is an additional $50K. This covers all of our baseline expenditures and allows us to invest and spend aggressively in our retirement. (We are 73 and 71).

  10. I came around to the Boglehead way of thinking a few months after I purchased an income annuity, but I have zero regret about the purchase and the downsides you mentioned in the article don’t cancel out the benefits that drove me to make the purchase in the first place.

    I have responses to some of your points. First, you questioned the credibility of studies that have shown annuity owners spend more in retirement, but you don’t actually provide any basis for questioning those studies. That’s kind of a cheap rhetorical trick. Even before I was a boglehead-oriented investor I was a data driven person. I’ve seen the data on retirees and annuities. The results actually make sense intuitively and there were zero red flags that I observed in terms of credibility behind the data.

    Recent empirical research—most notably by retirement researchers David Blanchett and Michael Finke (2024)—analyzed longitudinal spending patterns in the University of Michigan’s Health and Retirement Study (HRS). They found that at the margin, retirees spend roughly twice as much each year from guaranteed income wealth (annuitized streams, pensions, Social Security) as they do from equivalent values of non-annuitized investment wealth.

    Blanchett and Finke’s landmark studies (such as “Retirees Spend Lifetime Income, Not Savings” and “Guaranteed Income: A License to Spend”) do not rely on small, corporate consumer surveys. Instead, they use econometric models applied to the Health and Retirement Study (HRS)—a massive, longitudinal panel study tracking thousands of Americans over age 50, managed by the University of Michigan and funded by the National Institute on Aging.

    Their papers rely on standard econometric tools, such as Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regressions, controlling for asset levels, age, and health status to isolate how different forms of wealth impact marginal propensity to consume. From a pure research design perspective, their isolation of the behavioral disparity between how people treat income streams versus investment capital is methodologically sound and has been heavily cited across the discipline.

    You suggest that investors who read that data are somehow so impressed by it that they blindly follow the masses into annuities without doing any due diligence or any assessment of whether an annuity is right for their situation. That’s pretty condescending, and I can assure you that an annuity purchase is a major financial decision that I took very seriously, and I’ve yet to talk to an annuity owner who just signed in the dotted line because they read somewhere that people spend more when they own annuities.

    You said that annuities cause retirees to give up spending flexibility. This can be true if you don’t size your annuity appropriately. The ideal use of an annuity is to only size it large enough to cover a portion of your fixed expenses. You’re free to invest outside the annuity, and a lot of people are fine with fairly aggressive investment when they know their fixed expenses are covered. By capping the size of the annuity at that level, you absolutely retain plenty of flexibility to increase or decrease discretionary spending. This is rational, as we generally need stability when it comes to fixed expenses and flexibility when it comes to discretionary expenses.

    Regarding taxes: First, when it comes to income annuities, the exclusion ratio only applies to SPIAs and DIAs, not FIAs with income riders. With FIAs with income riders, your income is deemed mostly return of principal during the first decade of the contract. This is actually helpful as it maximizes your level of net income at the time you need it most, when you are most exposed to sequence of returns risk.

    For those who have SPIAs and DIAs, the exclusion ratio is not some kind of weird tax penalty. It’s just a formula that spreads taxation across the life of the contract that may or may not be useful for the retiree, and every retiree is free to determine if that type of taxation is compatible with their plan. The taxation overall isn’t any more or less fair than the taxation we all are subject to over the course of our lives on all our money.

    You stated “There is no Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation when it comes to annuities.” And then you referred to the collection of guaranty agencies in every state that actually do protect annuity owners as a “patchwork” that creates opportunities for annuity companies to hide in places that have poor state guaranty coverage.

    The controlling guaranty association and limits are determined entirely by the buyer’s state of legal residence at the time the insurance company becomes insolvent. There is no sneaky opportunity to escape guaranty protections by planting your insurance company in a low protection state. Also, there’s zero incentive to do that, as the state guaranty associations are post-insolvency safety nets, meaning they are essentially dormant entities until a company officially fails. And the coverage offered by state guaranty agencies isn’t capricious or spotty. Most of them protect your money up to $250,000.

    AM Best has tracked annuity providers and the results show that although the risk of a single insurer going under is non-zero, it’s also true that A- rated companies have needed some kind of regulatory or rehabilitative intervention 0.24% of the time, and even when that has happened, there is little to be concerned about. Stress tests have included the junk bond crisis of the 1990s when Executive Life Insurance Company collapsed and the 2008 global financial crisis. In neither situation were annuity holders materially harmed. In the case of the Executive Life Insurance collapse, annuity holders either received nearly all of their money back or their contracts were transferred to other providers. In 2008, when the global banking system nearly collapsed and commercial real estate and equities were in severe distress, not a single major active annuity provider with ongoing obligations failed.

    Also, you frame annuities as though they are an either/or option that must be compared to the benefits and risks of an index fund. That misses the point about annuities entirely. They are not a tool that typically replaces an index fund allocation. They are best used as a form of fixed income that can compare quite well against other fixed income options, including bonds. They aren’t always the best option, but they often can be.

    I do think you missed an opportunity to more directly critique the concept of an income annuity. A strong argument can be made that annuities don’t compare well with TIPS ladders. The lack of inflation adjustment is a significant downside to annuities, and TIPS ladders handle that issue very well. If TIPS yield had been as great when I bought my annuity as it is today, I probably would have skipped the annuity purchase and just gone all in with my fixed income allocation to a TIPS ladder. Instead, I fortunately had plenty of fixed income room left after I bought my annuity. When TIPS yields yield rose recently, I was able to pounce on the opportunity and I now have a 20-year TIPS ladder sitting alongside my income annuity. While the annuity plus social security address longevity risk, the TIPS ladder plus social security (and my large VT holding) hedge inflation risk.

    I’m not here to say that annuities are the amazing all upside no downside slam dunk option that a lot of salespeople will try to suggest. The problem with many sales pitches is that they present annuities as a magically safe alternative to equities, when they’re actually just a fixed income alternative that sometimes beat other options and sometimes do not. I’m saying a they’re a tool with positives that include lower longevity risk and yes higher freedom to spend when the totally decoupled market is going to crap and your index funds are in the toilet.

    They have their negatives as well, mainly the exposure to inflation erosion. The other problems with annuities that are often discussed are fees and several mechanisms in annuity contracts that dramatically cap your upside. These concerns aren’t relevant when you’re in it for the income. The only thing that matters is whether the level of income you’re getting is sufficient to meet your needs. Behind the scenes the fees will get paid and growth may or may not happen and it won’t matter at all, as you will continue to receive the level of guaranteed income you signed up for, full stop.

    1. You wrote “you questioned the credibility of studies.”

      I did no such thing. The text in the post states: Have you or I validated those studies? I certainly have not, and you most likely have not.

      But let’s go with them for a moment. Let’s assume the studies are valid just for the sake of argument.

      That is punting on assessing the validity of the studies.

      My entire argument on the studies is they don’t apply to the vast majority of my readers. It is not that the studies are valid or invalid.

      1. hello fitaxguy,
        Thanks for posting your article. I suspect one of the differences found in peoples’ take on Annuities is their balance of savings at what was for me “unexpected but grateful” retirement at 58 yo. I’m middle of the road, neither wealthy or poor, $500K investments, homeowner-no mortgage when I retired. People with $1-3M or more are in a different mindset entirely, because there’s more leeway for poor market returns. I saw annuities as a guaranteed way to cut the market risk and add a stable income, AT A COST for “certainty” of a monthly paycheck.

        FYI: Here’s a recent (9/2026) Vanguard study showing the benefit on dollars LEFT in investments at end of life AND higher monthly withdrawals for basic expenses by adding an income annuity to cover basic costs:
        See
        Beyond RMDs: A better way to turn retirement savings into income

        https://workplace.vanguard.com/insights-and-research/perspective/beyond-rmds-a-better-way-to-turn-retirement-savings-into-income.html

        And see section titled “The return of the paycheck” with subtitles “Real paycheck:” and “Partial annuity paycheck:”.
        Study authors’ conclusion:
        The approaches differ depending on what matters most: current income or financial flexibility. Certainly, there’s no “right” approach that works for everyone. However, the real paycheck and partial annuity paycheck can provide a steady flow of income through retirement while preserving money for later-life expenses (Figure 3A).

        1. Thanks for your comments.

          I don’t put too much stock into financial institutions’ studies on retirement income products. Remember, financial institutions market those products to varying degrees.

          1. Well, the ability to research similar studies is at all of our fingertips. I’ve done my due diligence, and I’ve experienced the grateful certainty of a known income in retirement with probable greater leeway and more $ at the end of life. I don’t think I need more than that 🙂

          2. Wait, I thought we agreed that you weren’t questioning the credibility of these studies. Anyway, the specific issue of financial institutions funding the studies certainly needs to be acknowledged, but so does the fact that the underlying empirical data Blanchett analyzed relied on neutral public datasets like the University of Michigan’s Health and Retirement Study (HRS).

          3. In the article, I RAISE (not question) the studies commentators raised, which, to my knowledge, were done by individuals — you yourself cited several INDIVIDUALS who did a study or studies. Kat cited to one specific study. That study was quite obviously done/sponsored by a FINANCIAL INSTITUTION. To my mind that is quite different that an individual researcher doing a study.

  11. Okay so you raised the issue of credibility and then set it aside for the sake of argument. Fair enough. I do think, though, that rhetorically you’re intentionally sowing doubt about the studies by framing it that way, otherwise there’d be no reason to even raise the issue and then dismiss it.

    Since your main point was that the studies, if valid, don’t apply to most of your readers, I’ve gotta say that’s a pretty broad stroke, and I’d be surprised if droves of rational investors would look at a guaranteed income vehicle and say no thanks on the face of it, as I’m dead set on sticking with total return no matter what.

    It’s probably likely that a lot of your readers would simply do a clinical assessment of the benefits and tradeoffs of annuities and make a rational choice based on the analysis, and it’s not a stretch to suggest that many of them would dispassionately view those studies as data points that may or may not speak to their own interest in securing income in retirement, which is a universal concern.

    You’re correct that we are not lemmings who follow the crowd without regard to personal finance and investing. But what’s the point of bringing these studies up as part of your critique of annuities? If they’re valid (they definitely appear to be) then they’re simply describing one of the benefits of owning an income annuity, i.e. income security that promotes healthy spending behavior. Some of the very readers your referring to have already posted comments on this article explaining that benefit of income security absolutely appeals to them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *