In my last post, I discussed the basics of the Backdoor Roth IRA, which can be a great planning tool for some higher income Americans. But not everyone qualifies for a tax-efficient Backdoor Roth IRA. Recall Jennifer’s case:
Jennifer makes too much to qualify to make a Roth IRA contribution in 2022. She contributed $6,000 to a nondeductible traditional IRA on April 19, 2022. She also had a separate traditional IRA with no basis. As of December 31, 2022, that separate traditional IRA was worth $93,998.53.
If, in 2022, Jennifer were to convert the $6,000 that she put into the nondeductible traditional IRA to a Roth IRA she would increase her taxable income by over $5,600. Ouch!
Options
Jennifer has two possible options to qualify for a much more tax efficient Backdoor Roth IRA. The first option is to use her workplace 401(k), 403(b), or 457 plan. Some 401(k) plans and other workplace plans allow participants to “roll in” amounts in traditional IRAs. Workplace plans are not required to offer participants this option. If a workplace plan does, it can be worthwhile to consider this option in order to facilitate Backdoor Roth IRA planning.
Of course, there are considerations that go beyond income tax planning, including the quality of the investment choices available in a traditional IRA versus a workplace 401(k) or other retirement plan, and the expenses associated with each option.
A second option is rolling the traditional IRA into a Solo 401(k) plan. Jennifer must have a Solo 401(k) plan from self-employment and the plan must accept IRA roll ins in order for her to do this. As with workplace retirement plans, Solo 401(k) plans are not required to accept traditional IRA roll ins, and any decision must appropriately consider the relevant non-tax issues (as discussed above). Further, a Solo 401(k) plan has several requirements (including the conduct of a trade or business) that should be carefully considered before opening a Solo 401(k).
Considerations
Trustee-to-Trustee Rollover
If Jennifer wants to roll her traditional IRA into a workplace retirement plan or Solo 401(k), she should structure the transfer as a “trustee-to-trustee” direct rollover of the money between the financial institution holding the traditional IRA and the workplace retirement plan or Solo 401(k). If instead of a trustee-to-trustee direct rollover, Jennifer receives a check from her IRA financial institution payable to her, she has 60 days to roll over that check (i.e., to get it to her workplace retirement plan or Solo 401(k)). If she does not move the money within the 60 days, the distribution from the IRA is taxable, subject to early withdrawal penalties if Jennifer is under age 59 ½, and cannot be transferred into a retirement plan.
Timing
Roll ins should be completed by December 31st of the year of the Roth IRA conversion. Otherwise the pro-rata rule will bite, because there will be a balance in the taxpayer’s traditional IRAs at year-end. That balance will attract a sizable portion of the $6,000 of IRA basis established by the nondeductible traditional IRA contribution. This causes the Roth IRA conversion to grab little basis and thus be tax inefficient.
For simplicity’s sake, it is usually best to clean out traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and SIMPLE IRAs and then make the nondeductible traditional IRA contribution.
Basis
Prior to implementing a traditional IRA to 401(k) “roll-in” strategy, Jennifer should review all of her traditional IRAs to ensure that she has no basis in any existing traditional IRA. IRA basis amounts cannot be rolled into the 401(k) and must be left behind under the rule of Section 408(d)(3)(A)(ii) and this technical write up.
SIMPLE IRAs and SEP IRAs
Those with amounts in SIMPLE IRAs, need to be careful. During the first two years of the SIMPLE IRA account, it cannot be rolled into a plan other than another SIMPLE IRA plan. Doing so would create a taxable event, subject to both early withdrawal and excess contribution penalties (on the transfer to the non-SIMPLE IRA).
Thus, if Jennifer’s traditional IRA balance is in a SIMPLE IRA and she first deposited into the SIMPLE IRA less than two years ago, she must wait until the two year window has expired to roll her SIMPLE IRA into a workplace retirement plan or a Solo 401(k).
In addition, those with a SIMPLE IRA (beyond the two year window) or a SEP IRA from their current employer may not be allowed in-service distributions. Thus, they would not be able to roll over those accounts into a 401(k)/Solo 401(k)/403(b)/457. Additionally, amounts may be added to these accounts prior to December 31st. These considerations make it difficult to successfully execute Backdoor Roth IRA planning for those currently covered by an employer’s SIMPLE IRA or SEP IRA.
December 31st
Any Backdoor Roth IRA planning should involve an additional diligence step: ensuring that as of December 31st of the year of the Roth conversion step, the taxpayer has a zero balance in all traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and SIMPLE IRAs. This helps ensure the Backdoor Roth IRA is a tax-efficient tactic.
Illustrative Example
Jennifer expects to earn $300,000 from her W-2 job in 2022, is covered by a workplace 401(k) plan, and expects to have some investment income. On March 1, 2022, Jennifer has a $90,000 balance in a traditional IRA but otherwise has no balance in a traditional IRA, SEP IRA, or SIMPLE IRA.
On March 2, 2022, Jennifer directs her workplace 401(k) plan and her IRA custodian to roll her traditional IRA to her workplace 401(k) plan. Her traditional IRA is rolled into her workplace 401(k) through a trustee-to-trustee direct rollover.
Jennifer contributes $6,000 to a traditional IRA on April 20, 2022. The contribution is nondeductible. Because the contribution is nondeductible, Jennifer gets a $6,000 basis in her traditional IRA. Jennifer must file a Form 8606 with her 2022 tax return to report the nondeductible contribution.
On May 2, 2022, Jennifer converts all the money in her traditional IRA to a Roth IRA (a Roth IRA conversion). At that time, Jennifer’s traditional IRA had a value of $6,001.47. Jennifer also ensures that as of December 31, 2022, she has a $0 balance in all traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and SIMPLE IRAs.
If Jennifer executes the above steps as described above, she will get the desired result. Done in this manner, the Roth IRA conversion step results in an increase in Jennifer’s taxable income of just $1.47 ($6,001.47 fair market value less $6,000 of traditional IRA basis).
Tactics vs. Goals
What if Jennifer’s workplace retirement plan does not accept roll ins? What if Jennifer doesn’t have access to a Solo 401(k)? What if Jennifer’s workplace retirement plan accepts roll ins but does not have quality investment options and/or charges high fees?
Remember, Jennifer’s ultimate goal is not to do a Backdoor Roth IRA. Her goal is financial independence! She should not let what I call the “tyranny of tactics” distract her from her ultimate goal.
The Backdoor Roth IRA is a great tactic to employ toward achieving that goal. But it’s okay if you can’t use this particular tactic. Plenty of people have and will achieve financial independence without executing a Backdoor Roth IRA.
If you can’t use the Backdoor Roth IRA for whatever reason, simply use other appropriate tactics, including but not limited to a high savings rate, to achieve your financial goals.
Further Reading
I discuss how to properly report a Backdoor Roth IRA on a tax return and what to do if has been incorrectly reported here.
FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com
Follow me on Twitter: @SeanMoneyandTax
This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.