Tag Archives: FI for Beginners

Understanding Your Form 1099-DIV

I suspect you’re here because you recently received a bill from your financial institution. It’s called a Form 1099-DIV. Oddly, the financial institution isn’t demanding a penny of payment. Rather, your 1099-DIV prompts the IRS and your state tax agency (in most states) to expect the payment of income tax with respect to your financial assets.

A Form 1099-DIV is a great window into your taxable investments. By learning how to read the major boxes of your 1099-DIV, you can gain valuable insights about your investments and their tax efficiency.

1099-DIV Basics

Form 1099-DIV exists so that taxpayers and the IRS know the income generated by financial assets in dividend paying accounts. These include stocks, mutual funds, and exchange traded funds (“ETFs”). The financial institution prepares the Form 1099-DIV and submits a copy to the IRS and a copy to the taxpayer. 

Let’s be clear about what we are talking about. We are not talking about assets in retirement accounts (401(k)s, IRAs, Roth accounts, HSAs, etc.). You do not receive a Form 1099-DIV from a retirement account regardless of how much money the account earned during the year. This is one of the advantages of saving through a retirement account. Dividends and other income generated by assets in a retirement account are not taxable to the account holder when generated, so long as the funds stay in the retirement account.

Dividends

Corporations pay dividends to their shareholders as a return to the shareholders of their portion of some or all of the earnings of the corporation. The corporation’s Board of Directors vote from time to time to pay dividends to the shareholders. Boards determine dividends based on a variety of factors, including the company’s profitability, industry, stage in the corporate life cycle, and business cash needs.

All shareholders of a corporation receive dividends. Some of those shareholders are themselves mutual funds or ETFs. Mutual funds and ETFs distribute out dividends and certain other income they receive (such as interest) to their shareholders as dividends.

1099-DIV Box 1a and Box 1b

Box 1a lists the so-called “total ordinary dividends” received from the account. That is all of the dividends paid by the stocks, mutual funds, and ETFs in the account. 

Box 1a should be understood as the entire pie. It represents all of the dividends received in the taxable account. The amounts in Box 1a are reported on line 3b of the Form 1040 (and on Schedule B if required).

Box 1b qualified dividends should be understood as a slice of the pie. It represents the portion of the total ordinary dividends that qualify for the long-term capital gains rates. Dividends create “ordinary income” for U.S. federal income tax purposes. However, certain “qualified dividends” (referred to as “QDI”) are taxed at preferential long term capital gains rates. As I have previously written, “[g]enerally, two requirements apply for the dividend to qualify for favorable QDI tax treatment. Very generally stated, they are:

  • The shareholder must own the stock for 60 of the 121 days around the “ex-dividend” date (the first date on which the stock sells without the right to receive the upcoming dividend); and,
  • The paying corporation must be incorporated either in the United States or in a foreign country with which the United States has a comprehensive income tax treaty.

Shareholders can obtain QDI treatment for stock owned through mutual funds and ETFs.

It may be that your qualified dividend slice is the entire pie. If the holding is a diversified index fund, there are usually some dividends that do not qualify for QDI treatment. 

Amounts reported in Box 1b are reported on line 3a of the Form 1040.

1099-DIV Box 2a Capital Gain Distributions

Box 2a is the danger zone of the Form 1099-DIV. In a way, it is unavoidable to recognize dividends (even if such dividends are QDI) if one wants to invest in a broad based portfolio of equities in a taxable account. Eventually corporations pay out dividends. While younger companies tend not to pay dividends, as companies mature they tend to start paying dividends.

What are much more avoidable (at least to a degree) are capital gain distributions. Capital gain distributions come from mutual funds and ETFs (they do not come from individual stocks).

Capital gain distributions occur when fund managers sell individual holdings at a gain. The fund is required to (usually toward year end) pay out those gains to the shareholders. The paid out gains are reported in Box 2a.

Three things tend to increase capital gain distributions: 1) active management; 2) a bull market; and 3) fund redemptions.

Active Management

Usually, this is the most significant factor in capital gain distributions. In order to actively manage a mutual fund or ETF, fund managers generally need to buy and sell different holdings. The selling of holdings is what creates capital gain distributions.

Frequent trading can make certain actively managed mutual funds and ETFs very tax inefficient, because they trigger capital gain distributions that are currently taxed to the owner at capital gains rates. 

From this, we can deduce the secret tax advantage of index funds. Index mutual funds and ETFs seek to simply replicate a widely known index. Other than occasional mergers and acquisitions of companies in the index, index fund managers rarely need to sell a holding to meet an investment objective. Thus, in many cases holding index funds in taxable accounts is tax efficient and will be better from a tax perspective than holding an actively managed fund.

Bull Market

Mutual funds and ETFs pass out capital gain distributions, not capital loss distributions. But in order for the shareholders to have a capital gain distribution, the mutual fund or ETF must (a) sell a holding and (b) must realize a gain on that sale.

In bear markets, it is often the case that the second requirement is not satisfied. The fund often realizes a loss on the sale of holding, meaning that the portfolio turnover does not generate a capital gain distribution reported in Box 2a. However, bear markets don’t always mean there will be no capital gain distributions, as active management and fund redemptions can still trigger capital gain distributions.

Fund Redemptions

There is an important distinction between mutual funds and ETFs in this regard. ETFs trade like public company stock — other than IPOs and secondary offerings, generally you buy and sell the stock of a public company and an ETF with an unrelated party that is not the issuer itself. 

Mutual funds, on the other hand, are bought and sold from the issuer. If I own 100 shares of the XYZ mutual fund issued by Acme Financial, when I redeem my 100 shares, Acme Financial buys out my 100 shares.

In order to buy out mutual fund shares, the mutual fund must have cash on hand. If it runs out of cash from incoming investments into the fund, it will have to sell some of its underlying holdings to generate the cash to fund shareholder redemptions. This creates capital gain distributions for the remaining shareholders. 

Interestingly, Vanguard has created a method to reduce the tax impact of mutual fund redemptions. Further, in recent times, fund redemptions have not caused significant capital gain distributions in many cases because in this current bull market mutual fund inflows often exceed outflows. 

1099-DIV Box 3 Nondividend Distributions

There are occasions where corporations make distributions to shareholders during a time where the corporation does not have retained earnings (i.e., it either has not made net income or it has previously distributed out is net income). Such distributions are not taxable as dividends. Rather, such dividends first reduce the shareholder’s basis in their stock holding. Once the basis has been exhausted, the distribution causes a capital gain.

1099-DIV Box 5 Section 199A Dividends

Section 199A dividends are dividends from domestic real estate investment trusts (“REITs”) and mutual funds that own domestic REITs. These dividends are reported on Form 8995 or Form 8995-A and qualify for the Section 199A QBI deduction. The good news is that the taxpayer (generally) gets a federal income tax deduction equal to 20 percent of the amount in Box 5. This deduction does not reduce adjusted gross income but does reduce taxable income.

Note that some early retirees might find out they do not qualify to claim the Section 199A deduction for Section 199A dividends. 

Section 199A dividends are another slice of the pie of Box 1a ordinary dividends.

1099-DIV Box 7 Foreign Tax Paid

An amount in Box 7 is generally good news from a federal income tax perspective. Many countries impose a tax on the shareholder when the corporation pays a dividend to a non-resident shareholder. The corporation withholds a percentage of the dividend and then remits the net amount of the dividend to the shareholder. 

The amount in Box 7 usually creates a foreign tax credit that reduces federal income tax dollar for dollar. Those with $300 or less in foreign tax credits ($600 or less if married filing jointly) can simply claim the foreign tax credit on Form 1040 without any additional work. If foreign tax credits exceed these amounts, a Form 1116 is needed to claim the foreign tax credit.

1099-DIV Boxes 11 and 12 Exempt-Interest Dividends and Private Activity Bond Interest

Box 11 represents all of the tax-exempt dividends received in the taxable account. Typically this is generated by state and municipal bond interest received by the mutual fund or ETF and passed out to the shareholders. This income is tax-exempt for federal income tax purposes.

This income may not be tax-exempt for state tax purposes. For example, in my home state of California, this income is taxable unless it is established that 50 percent or more of the fund’s assets are invested in California state and municipal bonds. In that case, the exempt-interest dividend attributable to California state and municipal bonds is tax-exempt for California purposes. The financial institution must separately provide the percentage of income attributable to California bonds to the shareholder in order to compute the amount of exempt-interest dividend exempt from California income tax. 

Box 12 is a subset of Box 11 (Box 11 is the whole pie, Box 12 is a slice). Box 12 dividends are those attributable to private activity bonds. The significance is for alternative minimum tax (“AMT”) purposes. While this income is tax-exempt for regular federal income tax purposes, it is not tax-exempt for AMT purposes (and thus is subject to the AMT). After the December 2017 tax reform bill this issue still exists, though it affects far fewer taxpayers.

Conclusion

The Form 1099-DIV conveys important information, all of which must be properly assessed in order to correctly prepare your tax return. It can also provide valuable insights into the tax-efficiency of your investments. 

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on LinkedIn: @SeanWMullaney

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here. 

2025 Year-End Tax Planning

It’s that time of year again. The air is cool and the New York Jets season is over. That can only mean one thing when it comes to personal finance: time to start thinking about year-end tax planning.

I’ll provide some commentary about year-end tax planning to consider, with headings corresponding to the timeframe required to execute. 

As always, none of this is advice for your particular situation but rather it is educational information. 

Urgent

By urgent, I mean those items that (i) need to happen before year-end and (ii) may not happen if taxpayers delay and try to accomplish them late in the year. 

Taxable Roth Conversions

Before we talk about taxable Roth conversion timing, we must talk about taxable Roth conversion desirability. Taxable Roth conversion desirability has significantly declined in recent years. Many commentators have not caught up to the new reality.

Fortunately, Mike Piper knows what time it is. At the 2024 Bogleheads conference, he said “[Roth conversions] don’t usually improve financial security in retirement.” Cody Garrett and I also acknowledge and tackle the changed landscape in our new book Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement. 

Yes, there can be some taxable Roth conversions that are highly advantageous. But they tend to be much more limited in scope and scale than most commentators acknowledge. In our book, Cody and I detail the sorts of taxable Roth conversions that tend to be beneficial.  

Back to timing. For a Roth conversion to count as being for 2025, it must be done before January 1, 2026. That means New Year’s Eve is the deadline. However, taxable Roth conversions should be done well before New Year’s Eve because 

  1. It requires analysis (hopefully done with up-to-date thinking) to determine if a taxable Roth conversion is advantageous, 
  2. If advantageous, the proper amount to convert must be estimated, and 
  3. The financial institution needs time to execute the Roth conversion so it counts as having occurred in 2025. 

For those age 65 or older by year-end, the Roth conversion calculus should consider the new senior deduction.

Generally speaking it is not good to have federal and/or state income taxes withheld when doing Roth conversions!

Donor Advised Fund Contributions

The donor advised fund is a great way to contribute to charity and accelerate a tax deduction. My favorite way to use the donor advised fund is to contribute appreciated stock directly to the donor advised fund. This gets the donor three tax benefits: 1) a potential upfront itemized tax deduction, 2) removing the unrealized capital gain from future income tax, and 3) removing the income produced by the assets inside the donor advised fund from the donor’s tax return. 

In order to get the first benefit in 2025, the appreciated stock must be received by the donor advised fund prior to January 1, 2026. This deadline is no different than the normal charitable contribution deadline.

2025 is a great time to make a donor advised fund contribution. Why? Because of the new 0.5% of income haircut on itemized charitable deductions starting in 2026. Assuming one has high income in both years, 2025 might be more desirable than 2026. I walked through an example of how the new haircut reduces itemized charitable deductions with Brad Barrett on the ChooseFI podcast. 

Due to much year end interest in donor advised fund contributions and processing time, different financial institutions will have different deadlines on when transfers must be initiated in order to count for 2025. Donor advised fund planning should be attended to sooner rather than later. 

Adjust Withholding

This varies, but it is a good idea to look at how much tax you owed last year. If you are on pace to get 100% (110% if 2024 AGI is $150K or greater) or slightly more of that amount paid into Uncle Sam by the end of the year (take a look at your most recent pay stub), there’s likely no need for action. But what if you are likely to have much more or much less than 100%/110%? It may be that you want to reduce or increase your workplace withholdings for the rest of 2025. If you do, don’t forget to reassess your workplace withholdings for 2026 early in the year.

One great way to make up for underwithholding, particularly for retirees, is through an IRA withdrawal mostly directed to the IRS and/or a state taxing agency. Just note that for those under age 59 ½, this tactic may require special planning.  

Backdoor Roth IRA Diligence

The deadline for the Backdoor Roth IRA for 2025 is not December 31st, as I will discuss below. But if you have already completed a Backdoor Roth IRA for 2025, the deadline to get to a zero balance in all traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and SIMPLE IRAs is December 31, 2025. 

Year-End Deadline

These items can wait till close to year-end, though you don’t want to find yourself doing them on New Year’s Eve.

Tax Gain Harvesting

For those finding themselves in the federal 0% long-term capital gains tax bracket and with an asset in a taxable account with a built-in gain, tax gain harvesting prior to December 31, 2025 may be a good tax tactic to increase basis without incurring additional federal income tax. Remember, though, the gain itself increases one’s taxable income, making it harder to stay within the federal 0% long-term capital gains tax bracket. 

I’m also quite fond of tax gain harvesting that reallocates one’s portfolio in a tax efficient manner. 

Tax Loss Harvesting

The deadline for tax loss harvesting for 2025 is December 31, 2025. Just remember to navigate the wash sale rule. 

RMDs from Your Own Retirement Account

The deadline to take any required minimum distributions from one’s own retirement account is December 31, 2025. Remember, the rules can get a bit confusing. Generally, IRAs can be aggregated for RMD purposes, but 401(k)s cannot. 

RMDs from Inherited Accounts

The deadline to take any RMDs from inherited retirement accounts is December 31st. 

Can Wait Till Next Year

Traditional IRA and Roth IRA Contribution Deadline

The deadline for funding either or both a traditional IRA and a Roth IRA for 2025 is April 15, 2026. 

Backdoor Roth IRA Deadline

There’s no law saying “the deadline for the Backdoor Roth IRA is DATE X.” However, the deadline to make a nondeductible traditional IRA contribution for the 2025 tax year is April 15, 2026. Those doing the Backdoor Roth IRA for 2025 and doing the Roth conversion step in 2026 may want to consider the unique tax filing when that happens (what I refer to as a “Split-Year Backdoor Roth IRA”). 

HSA Funding Deadline

The deadline to fund an HSA for 2025 is April 15, 2026. Those who have not maximized their HSA through payroll deductions during the year may want to look into establishing payroll withholding for their HSA so as to take advantage of the payroll tax break available when HSAs are funded through payroll. 

The deadline for those age 55 and older to fund a Baby HSA for 2025 is April 16, 2026. 

2026 Tax Planning at the End of 2025

ACA, HDHP, and HSA Open Enrollment

It’s open enrollment season at work and November 1st starts ACA medical insurance open enrollment for 2026. Now is a great time to assess whether a high deductible health plan (a HDHP) is a good medical insurance plan for you. One of the benefits of the HDHP is the health savings account (an HSA).

New for 2026! All Bronze and Catastrophic ACA plans will qualify as HDHPs! This opens the door for many self-employed and early retired individuals covered by these plans to make deductible HSA contributions. These deductible contributions can increase Premium Tax Credits and lower income taxes. 

As I write this in mid-October 2025, the Premium Tax Credit is in flux. I do think many early retirees and self-employed individuals will benefit from considering a Bronze or Catastrophic plan. As I’ve said before, Bronze is Gold!

For those who already have a HDHP, now is a good time to review payroll withholding into the HSA. Many HSA owners will want to max this out through payroll deductions so as to qualify to reduce both income taxes and payroll taxes.

Self-Employment Tax Planning

Year-end is a great time for solopreneurs, particularly newer solopreneurs, to assess their business structure and retirement plans. Perhaps 2025 is the year to open a Solo 401(k). Often this type of analysis benefits from professional consultations.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on LinkedIn at @SeanWMullaney

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, legal, investment, medical, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, legal, investment, medical, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement Launch Day

It’s finally here! Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement launches today, September 23rd. It’s available at Amazon and other online retailers.

To mark the occasion, we discussed the book on yesterday’s episode of the ChooseFI podcast and today’s episode of the BiggerPockets Money podcast.

We will be on several more podcasts in the coming weeks and months discussing the book and its concepts. 

One I’m particularly excited about is this Friday’s BiggerPockets Money podcast episode where we discuss tax planning for the five phases of retirement drawdown. You can find that episode on September 26th on the BiggerPockets Money YouTube channel and on podcast players.

I have also put two special YouTube videos on my YouTube channel discussing concepts from the book. 

  • Today I posted a video discussing just how much tax a retired married couple might pay on a $40,700 Roth conversion using an example from the book. You might be very pleasantly surprised by the result.

A Favor Request

I speak for both Cody and myself when I say we are grateful for all of the support we have received for this project.

If you have purchased the book and read it, we humbly for one more favor. Please write an honest and objective review of the book on Amazon. The number and quality of reviews is vital to the book remaining one that Amazon recommends to its customers. 

We want to get word out about Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement. You can help us do that with an Amazon review! 

Thank you for considering our request.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on LinkedIn: @SeanWMullaney

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

The Tax Planning World Has Changed

The tax planning world has changed. Have I and my fellow advisors caught up?

Below I discuss three changes in the past three years. These recent changes make a big impact on retiree taxation. Most commentators and gurus have largely ignored these changes.

The world has changed. It’s time for financial planners and tax advisors to adjust their advice accordingly.

No RMDs Until Age 75

In September 2022 required minimum distributions (“RMDs”) began at age 72. RMDs make traditional retirement account balances in retirement accounts less desirable, since they require taxable distributions.

In December 2022, SECURE 2.0 became law. For those born in 1960 and later, it delayed the onset of RMDs until age 75. SECURE 2.0 moved the needle when it comes to the desirability of traditional retirement accounts since it cancelled the three most likely to occur RMDs.

How long do we expect people to live beyond age 75? Take a look at the most recent Social Security Trustees Report actuarial table. For the vast majority of Americans, RMDs will now impact a very small proportionate share of their lifetime. 

It’s time for advisors to question prioritizing a planning concern, RMDs, that now impacts a very small slice of most Americans’ lives. 

Permanently Extended Lower Tax Brackets and Higher Standard Deduction

In 2022, advisors were on alert.

Better do those Roth conversions before lower tax rates sunset in 2026 was the common refrain. To be fair, in 2022 the Internal Revenue Code stated that the lower tax rates and the higher standard deduction expired on New Year’s Day 2026. 

Since 2022, both the world and the Internal Revenue Code have changed.

The sunset never happened! In July 2025, the One Big Beautiful Bill permanently extended the previously “temporary” lower tax brackets and the higher standard deduction. In fact, the new bill slightly increased the higher standard deduction ($750 for singles, $1,500 for those married filing jointly).

Let’s think about what that means for taxes in retirement. RMDs that would have been taxed at 15%, 25%, and/or 28% will now be taxed at 12%, 22%, and 24%. That makes a big difference in planning, as the taxation of RMDs becomes less harmful. 

It gets better! Less of most Americans’ RMDs will be taxed in a taxpayer’s highest bracket, thanks to the higher standard deduction. The higher standard deduction drags taxable income down in retirement, decreasing the amount of an RMD subject to the taxpayer’s highest marginal tax bracket. 

Senior Deduction

New for 2025 is the senior deduction. It is up to $6,000 per person for those 65 or older by year end. Yes, it is subject to modified adjusted gross income (“MAGI”) phaseouts between $75,000 and $175,000 for singles and $150,000 to $250,000 for those married filing jointly. But those income phase outs still allow many rather affluent retirees to claim some or all of the senior deduction.

Many affluent retired couples will not show $150,000 of MAGI, especially prior to claiming Social Security. Even those with $200,000 of MAGI, a very limited cohort of affluent retired couples, get $6,000 of the potential $12,000 deduction. While the senior deduction may be more limited for affluent single retirees, many will be able to control income so as to qualify for some of the senior deduction.

The senior deduction helps with several retirement tax planning tactics and objectives. For some, the senior deduction opens the door wider for significant tax free taxable Roth conversions prior to collecting Social Security. For others, it will open the door to very significant Hidden Roth IRA distributions prior to collecting Social Security. The senior deduction also reduces the tax hit on RMDs, since it lowers the amount of the RMD subject to the taxpayer’s highest marginal tax rate. 

2025 Increased Deduction: Consider a married couple both turning 65 in 2025. On New Year’s Day, their 2025 standard deduction was $33,200. Pretty good. With the increased standard deduction and the new senior deduction, assuming their MAGI is $150,000 or less, their total combined 2025 “standard” deduction is now $46,700. Yes, the tax planning world has changed!

Senior Deduction Uncertainty

Some worry: doesn’t the senior deduction vanish in 2029?

Aren’t we back to the “temporary” tax cuts that lowered the tax brackets and increased the standard deduction? 

“Temporary” was simply the weigh station to “permanent” in that case. I strongly suspect something similar will happen with the senior deduction.

Let’s play out the politics. If Congress does nothing, in 2029, the senior deduction, the new deduction for tipped income, and the new deduction for overtime income all vanish overnight. Is it politically wise for Congress to allow seniors, waiters, waitresses, and many blue collar workers to face tax hikes? 

Congress tends to act in its own best interests. While there are no guarantees, the politics are well aligned for the senior deduction to be extended into 2029 and beyond. 

Tax Planning Impact

Fewer RMDs. Lower tax rates and a higher standard deduction. The senior deduction.

Three big changes in three years change tax planning.

We’ve heard commentators push for Roth 401(k) contributions during the working years and aggressive Roth conversions during the early part of retirement. Both tactics optimize for taxes in the later part of retirement. But we’ve just seen three changes in three years that significantly lower taxes later in retirement. 

If the goal is to pay tax when you pay less tax, it’s time to adjust our thinking. 

This is particularly true when it comes to Roth 401(k) contributions. These contributions, for most taxpayers, tend to cost a tax deduction at the taxpayer’s highest lifetime marginal tax rate. In a changed world where retiree taxation has been significantly reduced, that’s not likely to be good planning for most Americans. 

My view is that the new tax planning environment reduces the desirability of significant Roth conversions prior to collecting Social Security. As Mike Piper stated, one of the main benefits of Roth conversions is to reduce tax drag caused by RMDs. The new tax laws significantly reduce that tax drag. Thus, accelerating income tax through Roth conversions becomes much less desirable.

Tax Planning Resource For a Changed World

Cody Garrett, CFP(R), and I created a resource for the new tax planning landscape. 

Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement is a book that tackles the new realities of tax planning, including deep dives into accumulation planning, drawdown tactics, taxable Roth conversions, RMDs, the Widow’s Tax Trap, and the senior deduction. 

We also have an entire chapter titled Planning for Uncertainty. In that chapter we tackle the “What about future tax hikes?” question using history, logic, and reason. 

Conclusion

In football and in tax planning, the game changes. The recommendations advisors made four years ago may have been the right recommendations then. But big changes in the retirement tax landscape require advisors to reevaluate their strategies and tactics when it comes to tax planning. 

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on LinkedIn: @SeanWMullaney

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

Why I Don’t Worry Much About Sequence of Returns Risk

If there is a single article of faith in the personal finance world, it’s you’ve gotta worry! IRMAA! RMDs! Widow’s Tax Trap! 

You’re rich? Great, start worrying! There’s plenty to worry about. 

Hopefully most long time readers and YouTube viewers know I’m kidding since I’m a glass half-full type. Today I tackle one worry that sometimes dwarfs the previously mentioned three. Sequence of returns risk. People wonder if they should hold years of cash at retirement because of sequence of returns risk. 

What is Sequence of Returns Risk?

Broadly defined, sequence of returns risk is that during the early part of a lengthy retirement, one or more bad years will hit the stock market. The early retiree is no longer accumulating, drawing down, and losing equity value. If the market takes years to recover, this could significantly hamper the early retiree’s chance of financial success in retirement.

Karsten Jeske, known as Big Ern online, discusses sequence of returns risk here.  

Below I discuss five reasons I don’t worry about sequence of returns risk much as applied to well diversified retirees. 

Diversification

We tend to think our portfolio exists in a vacuum. It doesn’t. 

As Rick Ferri has observed, a well diversified equity portfolio rapidly declining will be accompanied by several offsetting things in the world. Policy makers and central banks are likely to take action, perhaps significant action. As the economy is down, layoffs are up and fellow retirees are feeling the pinch.

What’s happening to prices in that environment? Fewer businesses are paying for work travel and fewer retirees are staying at hotels. Fewer workers are getting bonuses and bidding up the price of grass-fed ribeyes at the supermarket. In environments where the entire economy is hurting, prices for goods and services are likely to be stable or themselves falling. 

Will it be good for the early retiree to have their well diversified equity portfolio tank in early retirement? No. But Rick Ferri’s observation that related factors reduce the adverse impact of significantly falling equity prices is very instructive as to the importance, or lack thereof, of sequence of returns risk.

Where sequence of returns risk worries me greatly is a situation where an early retiree has a very undiversified portfolio. Imagine Sean retires today and 80 percent of his equity portfolio is in Apple stock. Apple stock can drop for a host of reasons while the rest of the economy is booming. The price of steak, travel, accommodations, etc. could care less about the stock price of Apple. 

For the undiversified early retiree, sequence of returns risk is one of many very significant risks in early retirement and one worthy of spurring on major changes to a portfolio. 

Social Security

Many early retirees will receive significant Social Security benefits. Those benefits are not too far out in the future for the early retiree. Social Security benefits are not subject to sequence of returns risk. Further, Social Security benefits reduce the retiree’s reliance on their equities and bonds. 

You Won’t March Off the Cliff

People worry about financial failure caused by things like sequence of returns risk. Here’s the thing: you will not blindly march off the cliff when it comes to your spending, as Michael Kitces observed on the BiggerPockets Money podcast.  

Both subconsciously and consciously, retirees will adjust their spending in down markets. A 14 day vacation becomes a 10 day vacation. You eat out one less meal a week. A new Camry becomes a new Corolla or becomes a used Corolla. 

Spending adjustments during down markets can mitigate sequence of returns risk with little impact on lived experience quality. 

Market Bounce Backs

When discussing the sequence of returns risk issue, we need to consider two issues. First, how much of the portfolio does an early retiree need at any one moment in time? Yes, this year’s withdrawal at reduced equity prices hurts the early retiree. But the rest of the portfolio declining this year is not at detrimental this year. Further, the rest of the portfolio might bounce back spectacularly, as I’ll discuss below. 

Second, what is the investment horizon for an early retiree? For the 55 year old retiree, it could easily be 35 years.

Let’s picture Amelia. Amelia is retiring today (congratulations!) and is currently 60 years old. According to the most recent Social Security Trustees’ Report actuarial data, Amelia is expected to die, on average, a bit before her 84th birthday. Obviously most Americans do not do financial planning to account for living only to their average life expectancy. Amelia easily has a 30 year or more investment time horizon today.

If Amelia is invested in a well diversified portfolio (including both an equity allocation and a bond allocation), she has plenty of time to ride out a very significant dip in the stock market. Imagine the S&P 500 is down 38.49 percent during the first year of her retirement. That’s what happened to the S&P 500 in 2008. According to the Social Security Trustees’ Report actuarial data, she has about 22.65 years over which to make up for that loss. 

How many 22.65 year periods over the past 100 years has the American stock market not made up that sort of loss? 

Let’s consider a retired couple that has already battled through sequence of returns risk. On December 31, 2007, Mark and Mary retired at age 50 with a well diversified equity and bond portfolio. The S&P 500 was at 1,468.36. A year later it was at 903.25. Since then, Mark and Mary have been through March 2020, the year 2022 when the S&P 500 was down 18.1%, and the March/April 2025 stock market decline.

How are Mark and Mary doing today? Well, the S&P 500 is at 6,000.36 (June 6, 2025 close) and now Mark and Mary upgrade their airfare to first class.  

Is the market always guaranteed to bounce back? Surely not. But you might want to refer to the 110 year Dow Jones Industrial Average graph that JL Collins shares several times in the new version of The Simple Path to Wealth, including on page 52. 

Cash is Not a Free Lunch

Let’s discuss the most commonly applied technique to mitigate sequence of returns risk: holding significant amounts of cash and spending it down first in retirement. 

This tactic has drawbacks. Cash is subject to inflation risk. It’s a store of value, and storing value is increasingly difficult, in my opinion. Further, by investing in cash the retiree foregoes the chance to invest in equities or bonds, potentially reducing future expected return (sometimes referred to as “cash drag“). Lastly, in a taxable account significant cash balances generate inefficient ordinary income in the form of interest payments. 

Conclusion

When it comes to retiree portfolio construction, I view sequence of returns risk as being similar to the prospect that the New York Jets will finish in last place in the AFC East.

Are both risks real? Yes

Are both unpleasant? Yes

Do both present significant risks of financial failure in retirement for well diversified retirees: No!

Yes, I exaggerate by equating sequence of returns risk with the performance of the New York Jets. But for the five reasons I stated above, I do not believe that sequence of returns risk should be a significant factor in portfolio construction for most well diversified retirees.

Further Reading

If you’ve gotten this far, I suspect you might be thinking to yourself, “Sean, you’ve convinced me on sequence of returns risk. But I’m still losing sleep over RMDs, IRMAA, and the Widow’s Tax Trap!”

Don’t worry. Cody Garrett and I have you covered in Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement, our forthcoming book likely to be published later this year. Sign up to find out when the book will be published here. 

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on YouTube: SeanMullaneyVideos

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

FI Tax Strategies for Beginners

New to financial independence (FI or FIRE)? Are you steeped in financial independence, but confused about tax optimization?

If so, this is the post for you. It’s not “comprehensive tax planning for FI” but rather an initial primer on some basic financial independence tax planning tactics. I believe the three tactics here are the most compelling tactics for most pursuing financial independence. 

But first, a caveat: none of this is advice for your specific situation, but rather, this comprises a list of the top three moves I believe those pursuing financial independence should consider. No blog post (this one included) is a substitute for your own and your advisors’ analysis and judgment of your own situation.

ONE: Contribute Ten Percent to Your Workplace Retirement Plan

To start, your top retirement savings priority in retirement should be to contribute at least 10 percent of your salary to your workplace retirement plan (401(k), 403(b), 457, etc.). I say this for several reasons.

  • It starts a great savings habit.
  • Subject to vesting requirements, it practically guarantees that you will get the employer match your 401(k) has, if any.
  • Assuming a traditional retirement account contribution, it gets you a valuable tax deduction at your marginal tax rate.
  • It will be incredibly difficult to get to financial independence without saving at least 10 percent of your salary. 
  • Strive to eventually contribute the maximum allowed.

Here are some additional considerations.

Traditional or Roth 

In some plans, the employee does not have a choice – employee contributions are “traditional” deductible contributions. Increasingly, plans are offering the Roth option where the contribution is not deductible today, but the contribution and its growth/earnings are tax-free in the future.

This post addresses the traditional versus Roth issue. I strongly favor traditional 401(k) contributions over Roth 401(k) contributions for most people. The “secret” is that most people pay much more in tax during their working years than they do during their retired years, even if they have significant balances in their traditional retirement accounts. Thus, it makes more sense to take the tax deduction when taxes are highest and pay the tax when taxes tend to be much lower (retirement).

Bad Investments

I’d argue that most people with bad investments and/or high fees in their 401(k) should still contribute to it. Why? First, consider the incredible benefits discussed above. Second, you’re probably not going to be at that job too long anyway. In this video, I discuss that the average/median employee tenure is under 5 years. When one leaves a job, they can roll a 401(k) out of the 401(k) to the new employer’s 401(k) or a traditional IRA and get access to better investment choices and lower fees. 

Resource

Your workplace retirement plan should have a PDF document called a “Summary Plan Description” available in your workplace benefits online portal. Reviewing that document will help you figure out the contours of your 401(k) or other workplace retirement plan.

TWO: Establish a Roth IRA

For a primer on Roth IRAs, please read my Ode to the Roth IRA. Roth IRAs, like traditional IRAs, are “individual.” You establish one with a financial institution separate from your employer. 

Generally speaking, a Roth IRA gives you tax-free growth, and if done correctly, money withdrawn from a Roth IRA is both tax and penalty free. 

Roth IRA contributions can be withdrawn tax and penalty free at any time for any reason! The Roth IRA is the only retirement account that offers unfettered, tax-free access to prior contributions. Note, however, in most cases the best Roth IRA strategy is to keep money in the Roth IRA for as long as possible (so it continues to grow tax free!). 

Find out why the Roth IRA might be much better than a Roth 401(k). 

THREE: Invest in Taxable Accounts

Taxable accounts get a very bad rap. It turns out they can be incredibly valuable. 

First, they tend to be lightly taxed, even during our working years. In 2025, a $1 million investment in a broad based domestic equity index fund is likely to produce less than $13,000 of taxable income. Most of that income will qualify as “qualified dividend income” and thus be taxed at favored long-term capital gains rates. 

Second, taxable accounts are the perfect bridge from working to retirement. When an investor sells an asset in a taxable account, they don’t pay tax on the amount of the sale. They pay tax on the amount of the sale less their tax basis (their original investment plus reinvested dividends). Basis recovery, combined with favored long-term capital gains tax rates, makes living off taxable accounts first in retirement very tax efficient. 

Conclusion

Here are the top three tax moves I believe FI beginners should consider:

First, contribute 10 percent to your traditional 401(k) or other traditional workplace retirement plan, striving to eventually contribute up to the maximum.

Second, establish a Roth IRA.

Third, invest in taxable brokerage accounts.

Of course, this post is not tailored for any particular taxpayer. Please consult with your own tax advisor(s) regarding your own tax matters.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Subscribe to my YouTube Channel: @SeanMullaneyVideos

Follow me on X: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here. 

Backdoor Roth IRA Timing

Happy New Year! It’s Backdoor Roth IRA season, so let’s talk about the issue that refuses to go away . . . the timing of the two steps of the Backdoor Roth IRA. 

Recall that the Backdoor Roth IRA is a two-step transaction. First, there is a nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA. The second step is a relatively close-in-time conversion of the nondeductible traditional IRA contribution and any minor growth to a Roth IRA. Assuming the correct profile, this can move money into a Roth IRA for a year the person exceeds the Roth IRA contribution MAGI limits. 

If there are two steps of the Backdoor Roth IRA, that begs a question: Just how long do I have to wait between the two steps, i.e., how long does the nondeductible traditional IRA contribution have to sit in the traditional IRA prior to the Roth conversion step? A minute? A day? A month? A year?

In some, but not all, cases there may have to be a few days or even a few weeks between the two steps of the Backdoor Roth IRA. Dr. Jim Dahle discussed this on a recent episode of The White Coat Investor podcast. 

The Backdoor Roth IRA and the Step Transaction Doctrine

There has been a concern with the Backdoor Roth IRA: the step transaction doctrine, which can collapse steps into a single step. In theory, the two steps of the Backdoor Roth IRA can be viewed as a single step (a direct contribution to a Roth IRA), which creates an excess contribution (subject to a potential 6 percent penalty). Michael Kitces has written that he is concerned that, because the Roth conversion step might occur so soon after the nondeductible traditional IRA contribution, the step transaction doctrine can apply to the Backdoor Roth IRA. Kitces generally advocates waiting a year between the steps based on his step transaction doctrine concern. To my knowledge he has never changed his view on the issue. 

I believe Mr. Kitces is a bit of a lone voice on the issue these days. In fact, Kitces’ own colleague Jeffrey Levine disagrees with him on the issue. 

Two late 2010’s developments moved the needle in the practitioner community towards Mr. Levine’s view. First, the IRS, in informal comments, indicated they were not too concerned with the Backdoor Roth IRA. Second, the legislative history to 2017’s Tax Cuts and Jobs Act indicated that Congressional staffers believed the Backdoor Roth IRA was valid. I believe this second development was overblown, as legislative history, to the extent relevant, is relevant to the legislation then being passed. It is not relevant, to my mind, to prior legislation (the Backdoor Roth IRA enabling legislation passed in 2006 – see Section 512). That said, both developments were informative, though certainly not binding. 

Sean’s Take

I have never been too concerned with the Step Transaction Doctrine and the Backdoor Roth IRA. In 2019, I co-wrote a Tax Notes article (available behind a paywall) about the issue with Ben Willis, my former PwC colleague. We concluded that it is not appropriate to apply the step transaction doctrine to a taxpayer’s use of the explicit, taxpayer favorable IRA rules. I believe we made a good case that the step transaction should not apply to the Backdoor Roth IRA based on the contours of the doctrine.

The Backdoor Roth IRA and Section 408(d)(2)(B)

Since 2019, I have further developed my thinking. I now believe a little commented-on rule in the IRA statute is very instructive: Section 408(d)(2)(B).

Section 408(d)(2)(B) provides that all IRA distributions during the year are treated as a single distribution. As a result, the timing of IRA distributions is irrelevant. A January 1st distribution is treated the same as a March 29th distribution, which is treated the same as a December 31st distribution. Roth conversions are distributions from an IRA. 

By grouping all IRA distributions into a single distribution, the Internal Revenue Code tells us the timing of IRA distributions, including Roth conversions, during the year is irrelevant. 

It would be exceedingly odd to apply a judicial doctrine (the step transaction doctrine) to give that timing relevance when the Code strips away that relevance. Anyone arguing the step transaction doctrine applies to a Backdoor Roth IRA is saying that the step transaction doctrine should override the specific rule of Section 408(d)(2)(B) in determining the degree of relevance afforded to the timing of the Roth conversion step. 

I strongly believe it is not appropriate to apply the step transaction doctrine when the Internal Revenue Code itself gives us a rule telling us the timing of the Roth conversion is irrelevant. 

Backdoor Roth IRA Favored Timing

I have two beliefs. First, timing is irrelevant when doing the Backdoor Roth IRA. Second, my views are not guaranteed to yield a 9-0 Supreme Court decision 😉

Based on those two beliefs, I have a third. The most desirable Backdoor Roth IRA path is to wait until the end of a month passes and then do the Roth conversion step of the Backdoor Roth IRA. This is the old Ed Slott tactic and locks in an end-of-month statement showing some interest or dividends in the traditional IRA. 

It could look something like this:

Roger contributes $7,000 to his traditional nondeductible IRA on January 2, 2025 for 2025 and invests it in a money market fund. On February 1, 2025, he converts the entire amount, now $7,027, to a Roth IRA. He has no other IRA transactions during the year and on December 31, 2025 he has $0 balances in any and all traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and SIMPLE IRAs.

Oh no, Roger created $27 of taxable income on his Backdoor Roth IRA. We’ve finally found something worse than IRMAA!

All kidding aside, here’s what Roger’s 2025 Form 8606 could look like (pardon the use of the 2023 form, the latest version available as of this writing): 8606 Page 1 8606 Page 2 And, yes, Roger should convert the entire traditional IRA balance, not just the $7,000 originally contributed to the traditional IRA.

To my mind, this works as a good Backdoor Roth IRA. So now you say, But Sean, what about your first belief? I thought timing was irrelevant!

I respond, (A) see my second belief and (B) what’s the downside of my desired approach? 

$27 of taxable income creates $10 of federal income tax if Roger is in the highest federal tax bracket, and Roger will have $27 more protected from future tax by the Roth IRA. 

The Backdoor Roth IRA Should Not Exist

That the Backdoor Roth IRA exists is ridiculous. It is obnoxious that our tax laws are so complicated that one of the most prominent financial planners, Michael Kitces, could plausibly claim the step transaction doctrine adversely impacts the Backdoor Roth IRA.

Let’s end all of this and adopt a rule that notorious tax haven, Canada, has adopted: Eliminate the income limit on the ability to make an annual Roth IRA contribution! Canada’s Tax-Free Savings Account (their version of a Roth IRA) has absolutely no income limit on the ability to make a contribution. America should adopt that rule as a small part of what hopefully will be a dramatic simplification of American income tax laws in 2025.

Conclusion

I do not believe that the step transaction doctrine should apply to the Backdoor Roth IRA. I do not believe that the timing of the two steps is relevant for determining their ultimate federal income taxation. That said, I like waiting until the following month to do the Roth conversion step. 

Of course, the entirety of this article is simply academic commentary. It is not tax, legal, or investment advice for you or anyone else.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on X: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

2025 IRA Contributions for Beginners

There are only three types of annual contributions to individual retirement accounts (“IRAs”). They are:

  • Traditional, nondeductible contributions
  • Traditional, deductible contributions
  • Roth contributions

This post discusses when a taxpayer can make one or more of these types of annual contributions.

Let’s dispense with what we are not talking about. This post has nothing to do with annual contributions to employer retirement plans (401(k)s and the like) and self-employed retirement plans. We’re only talking about IRAs. The Individual in “IRA” is the key – anyone can set up their own IRA. IRAs are not pegged to any particular job or self-employment.

The above list is the exhaustive list of the possible types of annual contributions you can make to an IRA. But there is plenty of confusion about when you are eligible to make each of the three types of annual contributions.

Maximum IRA Contributions

The maximum amount anyone can contribute to an IRA (traditional and/or Roth) for 2025 is $7,000. For those age 50 or older by the end of 2025, the limit is $8,000.

Two notes on this. First the limit is shared between traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs. In theory, someone under age 50 could contribute $4,000 to a traditional IRA and $3,000 to a Roth IRA. In practice, contributions are rarely divided between the traditional and the Roth, but it does occasionally happen.

Second, the limits have an additional limit: the contribution cannot exceed earned income. This means that those fully retired cannot contribute to an IRA unless they have a spouse who has earned income. A fully retired person (or a homemaker) can use their spouse’s earned income as their earned income and contribute to what is often referred to as a Spousal IRA. 

Why Contribute to an IRA?

Why you would consider contributing to an IRA? The main reason is to build up tax-deferred wealth (traditional IRAs) and/or tax-free wealth (Roth IRAs) for your future, however you define it: financial independence, retirement, etc. A second potential benefit is the ability to deduct some annual contributions to traditional IRAs. A third benefit is some degree of creditor protection. States offer varying levels of creditor protection to traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs, while the federal government provides significant bankruptcy protection for traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs. 

Traditional Nondeductible IRA Annual Contributions

There’s are only one requirement to contribute to a traditional, nondeductible IRA for a taxable year:

  • You and/or your spouse have earned income during that taxable year.

That’s it! As long as you satisfy that requirement, you can contribute to a traditional nondeductible IRA, no further questions asked.

Example: Teve Torbes is the publisher of a successful magazine. He is paid a salary of $1,000,000 in 2025 and is covered by the magazine’s 401(k) plan. Teve can make up to a $7,000 nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA, and Teve’s wife can also make up to a $7,000 nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA.

There is no tax deduction for contributing to a traditional nondeductible IRA. The amount of your nondeductible contribution creates “basis” in the traditional IRA. When you withdraw money from the traditional IRA in retirement, a ratable portion of the withdrawal is treated as a return of basis and thus not taxable (the “Pro-Rata Rule”).

Example: Ted makes a $6,000 nondeductible traditional IRA contribution for each of 10 years ($60,000 total). When he retires, the traditional IRA is worth $100,000, and he takes a $5,000 distribution from the traditional IRA. Ted is over 59 ½ when he makes the withdrawal. Of the $5,000 withdrawal, Ted will include $2,000 in his taxable income, because 60 percent ($3,000 — $60,000 basis divided by $100,000 fair market value times the $5,000 withdrawn) will be treated as a withdrawal of basis and thus tax free.

Traditional nondeductible IRA contributions generally give taxpayers a rather limited tax benefit. However, since 2010 traditional nondeductible IRA contributions have become an important tax planning tool because of the availability of the Backdoor Roth IRA.

Making a nondeductible IRA contribution requires the filing of a Form 8606 with your federal income tax return.

Traditional Deductible IRA Annual Contributions

In order to make a deductible contribution to a traditional IRA, three sets of qualification rules apply.

ONE: No Workplace Retirement Plan

Here are the qualification rules if neither you nor your spouse is covered by an employer retirement plan (401(k)s and the like and self-employment retirement plans):

  • You and/or your spouse have earned income during that taxable year.

That’s it! As long as you satisfy that requirement and you and your spouse are not covered by an employer retirement plan, you can make a deductible contribution to a traditional IRA, no further questions asked.

Coverage by an employer retirement plan means either you or your employer contributed any amount to an employer retirement plan (on your behalf) during the taxable year. Coverage by an employer retirement plan includes coverage under a self-employment retirement plan.

Example: Teve Torbes is the publisher of a successful magazine. He and his wife are 45 years old. He is paid a salary of $1,000,000 in 2025. Neither he nor his wife is covered by an employer retirement plan. Teve can make up to a $7,000 deductible contribution to a traditional IRA, and Teve’s wife can also make up to a $7,000 deductible contribution to a traditional IRA.

TWO: You Are Covered by a Workplace Retirement Plan

Here are the deductible traditional IRA qualification rules if you are covered by an employer retirement plan:

  • You and/or your spouse have earned income during that taxable year.
  • Your modified adjusted gross income (“MAGI”) for 2025 is less than $89,000 (if single), $146,000 (if married filing joint, “MFJ”), or $10,000 (if married filing separate, “MFS”). 

Note that in between $79,000 and $89,000 (single), $126,000 and $146,000 (MFJ) and $0 and $10,000 (MFS), your ability to make a deductible contribution to a traditional IRA phases out ratably. Here is an illustrative example.

Example: Mike is 30 years old, single, and is covered by a 401(k) plan at work. Mike has a MAGI of $84,000 in 2025, most of which is W-2 income. Based on a MAGI in the middle of the phaseout range, Mike is limited to a maximum $3,500 deductible contribution to a traditional IRA.

Assuming he makes a $3,500 deductible IRA contribution, Mike has $3,500 worth of IRA contributions left. He can either, or a combination of both (up to $3,500) (a) make a contribution to a nondeductible traditional IRA, since he meets the qualification requirement to contribute to a nondeductible traditional IRA or (b) make a contribution to a Roth IRA, since he meets the qualification requirements (discussed below) to contribute to a Roth IRA.

THREE: Only Your Spouse is Covered by a Workplace Retirement Plan

Here are the deductible traditional IRA qualification rules if you are not covered by an employer retirement plan but your spouse is covered by an employer retirement plan:

  • You and/or your spouse have earned income during that taxable year.
  • Your MAGI for 2025 is less than $246,000 (MFJ) or $10,000 (MFS). 

Note that in between $236,000 and $246,000 (MFJ) and $0 and $10,000 (MFS), your ability to make a deductible contribution to a traditional IRA phases out ratably. 

Roth IRA Annual Contributions

Here are the Roth IRA annual contribution qualification rules.

  • You and/or your spouse have earned income during that taxable year.
  • Your MAGI for 2025 is less than $165,000 (single), $246,000 (MFJ), or $10,000 (MFS). 

Note that in between $150,000 and $165,000 (single), $236,000 and $246,000 (MFJ), and $0 and $10,000 (MFS), your ability to make a Roth IRA contribution phases out ratably. 

Notice that whether you and/or your spouse are covered by an employer retirement plan (including a self-employment retirement plan) is irrelevant. You and your spouse can be covered by an employer retirement plan and you can still contribute to a Roth IRA (so long as you meet the other qualification requirements).

Here is an example illustrating your options in the Roth IRA MAGI phaseout range.

Example: Mike is 30 years old, single, and covered by a workplace retirement plan. Mike has a MAGI of $159,000 for 2025, most of which is W-2 income. Based on a MAGI 60 percent through the phaseout range, Mike is limited to a maximum $2,800 contribution to a Roth IRA.

Assuming he makes a $2,800 annual Roth IRA contribution, Mike has $4,200 worth of IRA contributions left. He can make up to $4,200 in annual contributions to a nondeductible traditional IRA, since he meets the qualification requirement to contribute to a nondeductible traditional IRA.

Deadlines

The deadline to make an IRA contribution for a particular year is April 15th of the year following the taxable year (thus, the deadline to make a 2025 IRA contribution is April 15, 2026). The deadline to make earned income for a taxable year is December 31st of that year.

Rollover Contributions

There’s a separate category of contributions to IRAs: rollover contributions. These can be from other accounts of the same type (traditional IRA to traditional IRA, Roth IRA to Roth IRA) or from a workplace retirement plan (for example, traditional 401(k) to traditional IRA, Roth 401(k) to Roth IRA). 

Rollover contributions do not require having earned income and have no income limits and should be generally tax-free. For a myriad of reasons, it is usually best to effectuate rollovers as direct trustee-to-trustee transfers. 

As a practical matter, it is often the case that IRAs serve at the retirement home for workplace retirement plans such as 401(k)s. 

Further Reading

Deductible traditional IRA or Roth IRA? If you qualify for both, it can be difficult to determine which is better. I’ve written here about some of the factors to consider in determining whether a deductible traditional contribution or a Roth contribution is better for you.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on X at @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

2024 Year-End Tax Planning

It’s that time of year again. The air is cool and the Election is in the rear-view mirror. That can only mean one thing when it comes to personal finance: time to start thinking about year-end tax planning.

I’ll provide some commentary about year-end tax planning to consider, with headings corresponding to the timeframe required to execute. 

As always, none of this is advice for your particular situation but rather it is educational information. 

Urgent

By urgent, I mean those items that (i) need to happen before year-end and (ii) may not happen if taxpayers delay and try to accomplish them late in the year. 

Donor Advised Fund Contributions

The donor advised fund is a great way to contribute to charity and accelerate a tax deduction. My favorite way to use the donor advised fund is to contribute appreciated stock directly to the donor advised fund. This gets the donor three tax benefits: 1) a potential upfront itemized tax deduction, 2) removing the unrealized capital gain from future income tax, and 3) removing the income produced by the assets inside the donor advised fund from the donor’s tax return. 

In order to get the first benefit in 2024, the appreciated stock must be received by the donor advised fund prior to January 1, 2025. This deadline is no different than the normal charitable contribution deadline.

However, due to much year end interest in donor advised fund contributions and processing time, different financial institutions will have different deadlines on when transfers must be initiated in order to count for 2024. Donor advised fund planning should be attended to sooner rather than later. 

Taxable Roth Conversions

For a Roth conversion to count as being for 2024, it must be done before January 1, 2025. That means New Year’s Eve is the deadline. However, taxable Roth conversions should be done well before New Year’s Eve because 

  1. It requires analysis to determine if a taxable Roth conversion is advantageous, 
  2. If advantageous, the proper amount to convert must be estimated, and 
  3. The financial institution needs time to execute the Roth conversion so it counts as having occurred in 2024. 

Remember, generally speaking it is not good to have federal and/or state income taxes withheld when doing Roth conversions!

Gotta Happen Before 2026!!!

Before the Election, many commentators said “you’ve gotta get your Roth conversions done before tax rates go up in 2026!” If this were X (the artist formerly known as Twitter), the assertion would likely be accompanied by a hair-on-fire GIF. 😉

I have disagreed with the assertion. As I have stated before, there’s nothing more permanent than a temporary tax cut! Now with a second Trump presidency and a Republican Congress, it is likely that the higher standard deduction and rate cuts of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act will be extended. 

Regardless of the particulars of 2025 tax changes, I recommend that you make your own personal taxable Roth conversion decisions based on your own personal situation and analysis of the landscape and not a fear of future tax hikes.

Adjust Withholding

This varies, but it is a good idea to look at how much tax you owed last year. If you are on pace to get 100% (110% if 2023 AGI is $150K or greater) or slightly more of that amount paid into Uncle Sam by the end of the year (take a look at your most recent pay stub), there’s likely no need for action. But what if you are likely to have much more or much less than 100%/110%? It may be that you want to reduce or increase your workplace withholdings for the rest of 2024. If you do, don’t forget to reassess your workplace withholdings for 2024 early in the year.

One great way to make up for underwithholding is through an IRA withdrawal mostly directed to the IRS and/or a state taxing agency. Just note that for those under age 59 ½, this tactic may require special planning.  

Backdoor Roth IRA Diligence

The deadline for the Backdoor Roth IRA for 2024 is not December 31st, as I will discuss below. But if you have already completed a Backdoor Roth IRA for 2023, the deadline to get to a zero balance in all traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and SIMPLE IRAs is December 31, 2024. 

Solo 401(k) Planning

There’s plenty of planning that needs to be done for solopreneurs in terms of retirement account contributions. 

The Solo 401(k) can get complicated. That’s why I wrote a book about them and post an annual update on Solo 401(k)s here on the blog. 

Year-End Deadline

These items can wait till close to year-end, though you don’t want to find yourself doing them on New Year’s Eve.

Tax Gain Harvesting

For those finding themselves in the 12% or lower federal marginal income tax bracket and with an asset in a taxable account with a built-in gain, tax gain harvesting prior to December 31, 2024 may be a good tax tactic to increase basis without incurring additional federal income tax. Remember, though, the gain itself increases one’s taxable income, making it harder to stay within the 12% or lower marginal income tax bracket. 

I’m also quite fond of tax gain harvesting that reallocates one’s portfolio in a tax efficient manner. 

Tax Loss Harvesting

The deadline for tax loss harvesting for 2024 is December 31, 2024. Just remember to navigate the wash sale rule. 

RMDs from Your Own Retirement Account

The deadline to take any required minimum distributions from one’s own retirement account is December 31, 2024. Remember, the rules can get a bit confusing. Generally, IRAs can be aggregated for RMD purposes, but 401(k)s cannot. 

RMDs from Inherited Accounts

The deadline to take any RMDs from inherited retirement accounts is December 31st. For some beneficiaries of retirement accounts inherited during 2020, 2021, 2022, and 2023, the IRS has waived 2024 RMDs. That said, all beneficiaries of inherited retirement accounts may want to consider affirmatively taking distributions (in addition to RMDs, if any) before the end of 2024 to put the income into a lower tax year, if 2024 happens to be a lower taxable income year vis-a-vis future tax years. 

Can Wait Till Next Year

Traditional IRA and Roth IRA Contribution Deadline

The deadline for funding either or both a traditional IRA and a Roth IRA for 2024 is April 15, 2025. 

Backdoor Roth IRA Deadline

There’s no law saying “the deadline for the Backdoor Roth IRA is DATE X.” However, the deadline to make a nondeductible traditional IRA contribution for the 2024 tax year is April 15, 2025. Those doing the Backdoor Roth IRA for 2024 and doing the Roth conversion step in 2025 may want to consider the unique tax filing when that happens (what I refer to as a “Split-Year Backdoor Roth IRA”). 

HSA Funding Deadline

The deadline to fund an HSA for 2024 is April 15, 2025. Those who have not maximized their HSA through payroll deductions during the year may want to look into establishing payroll withholding for their HSA so as to take advantage of the payroll tax break available when HSAs are funded through payroll. 

The deadline for those age 55 and older to fund a Baby HSA for 2024 is April 15, 2025. 

2025 Tax Planning at the End of 2024

HDHP and HSA Open Enrollment

It’s open enrollment season. Now is a great time to assess whether a high deductible health plan (a HDHP) is a good medical insurance plan for you. One of the benefits of the HDHP is the health savings account (an HSA).

For those who already have a HDHP, now is a good time to review payroll withholding into the HSA. Many HSA owners will want to max this out through payroll deductions so as to qualify to reduce both income taxes and payroll taxes.

Self-Employment Tax Planning

Year-end is a great time for solopreneurs, particularly newer solopreneurs, to assess their business structure and retirement plans. Perhaps 2024 is the year to open a Solo 401(k). Often this type of analysis benefits from professional consultations.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on Twitter at @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, legal, investment, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, legal, investment, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

New to Financial Independence? Start Here!

Financial independence is great. But sometimes it can be daunting. Personal finance itself can be daunting, and now we’re adding something called financial independence or “FIRE” to it?

I decided it was time to come up with an approachable, understandable, and cost free entry point into financial independence. With the four resources listed below, I believe one can rather quickly get up to speed without needing any sort of advanced knowledge or education. The four resources, including one podcast episode, one very short academic article, and two blog posts, are free and easy to digest.

ChooseFI Episode 100: Welcome to the FI Community

This podcast episode goes over the basics of financial independence. 

The Shockingly Simple Math Behind Early Retirement by Mr. Money Mustache

This blog post discusses the math behind early retirement.

The Arithmetic of Active Management by William F. Sharpe

This very brief academic article compares active investing versus passive investing (generally speaking, index funds).

FI Tax Strategies for Beginners by Sean Mullaney

My blog post goes over the basic tactics of tax planning for FI beginners.


Obviously there are plenty more FI resources, and I encourage you to explore them. But my hope is that these four resources comprise a relatively easy on-ramp into financial independence and personal finance for those starting out.

Subscribe to my YouTube Channel: @SeanMullaneyVideos

Follow me on X: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, medical, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, medical, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.