Excess Contributions to an IRA

There are limits to how much can be contributed to traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs. This post describes how excess contributions happen and how to resolve them.

Three introductory notes. First, if you find that you have made an excess contribution, you may be well advised to seek professional advice. Second, please don’t panic, but make sure to act swiftly. Excess contributions are resolvable but do not benefit from delays. Third, you should not plan to make an excess contribution for a variety of reasons.

Traditional IRAs

There are (generally speaking) three situations that generate an excess contribution to a traditional IRA. They are:

  • Contributions are made for a year the taxpayer (and their spouse) does not have earned income.
  • Contributions are made in excess of the annual contribution limits.
  • Rolling into an IRA an amount that did not qualify to be rolled in.

This last category is not immediately obvious, but it does occasionally occur. For example, a taxpayer might inherit a taxable account and incorrectly roll it into an inherited IRA. Or a taxpayer might incorrectly roll an IRA they inherited into their own IRA. Or a taxpayer might attempt a 60-day rollover of amounts previously in an IRA and roll the money into an IRA after the 60-day deadline. Note that in some cases, this last mistake can be resolved by obtaining a private letter ruling from the IRS (doing so is beyond the scope of this post).

For 2019 and prior taxable years, there is an additional category: contributions to a traditional IRA when the taxpayer was 70 1/2 or older. The SECURE Act eliminates the prohibition on those 70 1/2 and older contributing to a traditional IRA.

Resolutions

Recharacterization

Prior to the 2020 tax year, if you qualified to make a contribution to a Roth IRA, but not to a traditional IRA, you could direct your financial institution to recharacterize the contribution to a Roth IRA. This scenario only applied in situations where the taxpayer was over age 70 ½ when the contribution was made to the traditional IRA.

Now there is no scenario where this would be relevant. Anyone not qualifying to make a contribution to a traditional IRA would also not qualify to make a contribution to a Roth IRA.

However, recharacterizations of contributions from traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs can make sense for some taxpayers for tax planning reasons, and are allowable if done properly.

To recharacterize, you must contact the financial institution and direct them to move the contribution and its earnings to a Roth IRA. This must be disclosed in a white paper statement attached to your federal income tax return. The recharacterization deadline is the extended due date of the tax return (generally October 15th).

Withdrawal

A second way to correct an excess contribution to a traditional IRA is to take a “corrective distribution” of the excess contribution and its earnings from the IRA. You will need to inform your financial institution of the excess contribution and request a corrective distribution of the excess contribution and the earnings attributable to the excess contribution. If the excess contribution is withdrawn prior to the extended filing deadline, the withdrawal of the contribution itself is generally not included in taxable income.

As observed in IRS Publication 590-A, page 34, in most cases the financial institution will compute the earnings attributable to the excess contribution. The earnings will be included in taxable income for the actual year the excess contribution was made. For example, if a 2023 IRA contribution is made in January 2024, and the taxpayer later takes a corrective distribution of that contribution and its earnings, the earnings will be includible in taxable income in 2024. In those cases where the taxpayer must compute the earnings, IRS Publication 590-A Worksheet 1-3 is a resource for figuring the earnings or loss.

See Example 1 in this article for insights on the reporting timing of earnings attributable to corrective distributions.

Up until the passage of SECURE 2.0, the earnings were also subject to the ten percent early withdrawal penalty (unless an exception otherwise applied). However, SECURE 2.0 Section 333 repealed the early withdrawal penalty with respect to withdrawals of earnings occurring pursuant to a corrective distribution. Note further that as of March 1, 2024 there is now some doubt as to the on going validity of SECURE 2.0.

If the corrective distribution occurs after the taxpayer files their tax return for the relevant taxable year, but before the extended filing deadline for the year (generally October 15th), the taxpayer must file an amended return which reports the corrective distribution.

A quick note on corrective distributions (as applied to both traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs): they can be done if the taxpayer has changed their mind. Natalie Choate makes this point in her excellent treatise Life and Death Planning for Retirement Benefits (8th ed. 2019, see page 132). Corrective distributions are not limited to simply those times when the taxpayer has made a contribution in excess of the allowed limits.

Apply the Contribution to a Later Year

You can keep an excess contribution in a traditional IRA and apply it to a later year, if you are eligible to make a traditional IRA contribution in that later year. This method does not avoid the six percent penalty discussed below for the year of the contribution, but it allows the taxpayer to avoid taking a distribution of the excess contribution and stops additional impositions of the six percent excess contribution penalty. Generally, this method is only effective if the amount of the excess contribution is relatively modest, since a large excess contribution cannot be soaked up by only one year’s annual IRA contribution limit.

Penalties

If you do not resolve the excess contribution prior to the extended deadline for filing your tax return, you must pay a six percent excise tax on the excess contribution annually until the excess contribution is withdrawn from the traditional IRA. You report and pay the excise tax by filing a Form 5329 with the IRS. Because this six percent tax is imposed each year the excess contribution stays in the traditional IRA, it is important to correct excess contributions to traditional IRAs promptly.

Note further that excess contributions withdrawn after the extended filing deadline are generally included in taxable income, though the taxpayer can recover a portion of any IRA basis they have under the Pro-Rata Rule.

Roth IRAs

There are (generally speaking) four situations that cause an excess contribution to a Roth IRA. They are:

  • Contributions are made for a year the taxpayer (and their spouse) does not have earned income.
  • Contributions are made in excess of the annual contribution limits.
  • Contributions are made for a year the taxpayer exceeds the modified adjusted gross income (“MAGI”) limitations to make a Roth IRA contribution)
  • Rolling into a Roth IRA an amount that did not qualify to be rolled in.

A rather common excess contribution occurs when taxpayers contribute to a Roth IRA in a year they earn in excess of the MAGI limits. That can happen for a host of reasons, including end of year bonuses or other unanticipated income.

Another somewhat common mistake in this regard is made by those subject to required minimum distributions (“RMDs”) when trying to convert traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs. In early January a taxpayer might convert a chunk of their traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. This creates a problem if the taxpayer did not previously take out their annual RMD for the year. There is a rule providing that RMDs are the first money to come out of an IRA during the year, and RMDs may not be converted to Roth IRAs. Thus, “converting” the first dollars out of a traditional IRA (an RMD) during the year creates an excess contribution to a Roth IRA.

Resolutions

Recharacterization

Assuming that the taxpayer qualifies to make a contribution to a traditional IRA, the excess contribution to a Roth IRA can be recharacterized as a contribution to a traditional IRA. Generally, the taxpayer must contact the financial institution and direct them to recharacterize the contribution and its earnings into a traditional IRA and must file a white paper statement with their tax return explaining the recharacterization.

Note that the recharacterization deadline is the extended due date of the tax return (usually October 15th).

Withdrawal

A second way to correct an excess contribution to a Roth IRA is to take a corrective distribution of the excess contribution. You will need to inform your financial institution of the excess contribution and request a corrective distribution of the excess contribution and the earnings attributable to the excess contribution. The withdrawal of the excess contribution itself is generally not taxable.

The financial institution will compute the earnings attributable to the excess contribution. The earnings will be included in taxable income for the actual year the excess contribution was made. The same inclusion timing rules applicable to traditional IRA corrective distributions (discussed above) apply to the earnings from a Roth IRA corrective distribution.

If the corrective distribution occurs after the taxpayer files their tax return for the relevant taxable year, but before the extended filing deadline for the year (generally October 15th), the taxpayer must file an amended return which reports the corrective distribution and includes the earnings in taxable income (if the original contribution actually occurred in the year covered by the tax return).

Apply the Contribution to a Later Year

As with excess contributions to traditional IRAs, you can keep an excess contribution in a Roth IRA and apply it to a later year, if you are eligible to make a Roth IRA contribution in that later year. This method does not avoid the six percent penalty discussed below for the year of the contribution, but it allows the taxpayer to avoid taking a distribution of the excess contribution and stops additional impositions of the six percent excess contribution penalty. Generally, this method is only effective if the amount of the excess contribution is relatively modest, since a large excess contribution cannot be soaked up by only one year’s annual Roth IRA contribution limit.

Penalties

As with excess contributions to traditional IRAs, if you do not resolve the excess contribution to your Roth IRA prior to the extended deadline for filing your tax return, you must pay a six percent excise tax on the excess contribution annually until the excess contribution is withdrawn. It is best to resolve an excess contribution to a Roth IRA sooner rather than later to avoid annual impositions of the penalty.

Tax Return Considerations

Corrective measures applied to traditional IRA and/or Roth IRA contributions may require tax return reporting. Such reporting is discussed in various sources. Examples of such sources include IRS Publication 590-A, the Instructions to the Form 8606, and/or the Instructions to the Form 5329.

Conclusion

Excess contributions to IRAs and Roth IRAs happen. They are not an occasion to panic. They are an occasion for prompt, well considered action. Hopefully this article provides enough background for you to start your decision process and, if necessary, have an informed conversation with a competent tax professional.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on Twitter: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.