Category Archives: Tax

Articles that are mostly tax focused

Recipe for Reporting a Backdoor Roth IRA

When it comes to the Backdoor Roth IRA, I’ve seen it all. Reporting a Backdoor Roth IRA on tax returns remains confusing for both taxpayers and tax return preparers. Here’s the recipe I recommend using to report the Backdoor Roth IRA on the tax return and avoid overpaying taxes.

Watch me discuss reporting Backdoor Roth IRAs on tax returns.

Let’s consider a hypothetical Backdoor Roth IRA on a 2021 tax return.

Example: On January 1, 2021, John Smith contributed $6,000.00 to a traditional IRA. On February 1, 2021, John Smith converted the entire amount in his traditional IRA, $6,001.00, to a Roth IRA. On December 31, 2021, John Smith had a zero balance in all his traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and SIMPLE IRAs. John Smith’s income is such that he qualifies for neither a deductible traditional IRA contribution nor a regular annual Roth IRA contribution. John has no existing basis in traditional IRAs as of January 1, 2021. 

Ingredients

Dry Ingredients

  • Taxpayer & Spouse Form W-2 and/or self-employed retirement contributions
  • The prior year’s Form 8606 (if the taxpayer has existing traditional IRA basis – most Backdoor Roth IRA taxpayers do not)

Wet Ingredients

  • Forms 5498 from financial institutions
    • If not available, substitute (i) end-of-year balances in all traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and SIMPLE IRAs and (ii) taxpayer knowledge or IRA account statement
  • Forms 1099-R from financial institutions

Directions

First, Enter the Dry Ingredients

In order to ensure that the tax return software has all the information to properly report the Backdoor Roth IRA, the taxpayer’s and spouse’s Forms W-2 (if any) should be properly entered into the tax return software. In particular, if Box 13 is checked, that should be indicated in the tax return software. Any qualifying self-employed retirement plan (Solo 401(k), SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA) contributions should also be entered into the software. This requires the computation of the Schedule C to validate the correctness of the self-employment retirement contributions. 

Lastly, any established and still existing traditional IRA basis reported on previously filed Forms 8606 must be entered into the software. For those who have properly done Backdoor Roth IRAs in the past, this is extremely rare, but not impossible. Most such taxpayers enter the year with $0 of such basis. 

None of these steps directly report the current year’s Backdoor Roth IRA. However, without properly completing them, the tax return software will be unlikely to report the Backdoor Roth IRA correctly. 

Second, Enter The Traditional IRA Contribution

The first step in the tax return process is entering the traditional nondeductible IRA contribution into the tax return software. In theory, this should come off the Form 5498 (Box 1). In practice, that is not likely. The Form 5498 is not required to be filed by the financial institution until May 31st. Vanguard, for example, provides these forms in mid-May. 

If the taxpayer has a Form 5498 when preparing their tax return (perhaps because they are filing the return on extension), Box 1 of the form should report the traditional IRA contribution. In most circumstances, taxpayers will use their own knowledge of the transaction or their IRA account statement to report that they made a $6,000 nondeductible traditional IRA contribution.

By entering the $6,000.00 traditional IRA contribution into the tax return software, John’s tax return should generate a Form 8606. This is crucial for two reasons. First, the nondeductible traditional IRA contribution must be reported. Second, the nondeductible contribution establishes the “basis” that keeps John’s Backdoor Roth IRA as almost entirely tax free. 

Note further that IRAs are a single person item, meaning that there is no such thing as a “joint” IRA. Each spouse must enter his or her information separately, and must file his or her own individual Form 8606 as needed. Where spouses can impact the calculations and reporting is the ability to deduct an IRA contribution where one spouse is covered by a workplace retirement plan and the other spouse is not. 

Third, Enter the Roth Conversion

This is where the tax return reporting can go a bit off the rails if one is not careful. Tax return software usually has an input for Forms 1099-R. The Form 1099-R should be entered into the tax return software. 

John’s Form 1099-R should look like this (please pretend it is for 2021):

It is important to input all of the boxes on the Form 1099-R in the tax return software to help ensure that the software understands the transaction and no penalties are charged (there should be none as the transaction is a Roth conversion).

Some worry about Box 2a reporting $6,001.00 as the “taxable amount.” It’s okay! The taxable amount is in fact $6,001.00. However, it must be remembered that taxpayers must pay tax on the taxable amount reduced by the allowed available basis. 

How do we know what the allowed available basis is? By preparing and filing the Form 8606! To prepare the Form 8606, we must have all the ingredients above. It will be important that the following information is input into the Form 8606:

  • Current year traditional IRA contribution ($6,000.00)
  • Current year Roth IRA conversion ($6,001.00)
  • Balance in all traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and SIMPLE IRAs on December 31, 2021 ($0 in John’s case)

At this point the first two data points are in the tax return software. The last one must now be added to the software. Assuming the tax return is prepared prior to May, the taxpayer needs to review all of their existing traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and SIMPLE IRAs to ensure that as of December 31, 2021 there were no balances in those accounts. If there were balances, they must be added up and reported on line 6 of the Form 8606.

The Finished Product

Here is what page 1 of John’s Form 8606 should look like out of the oven.

Because Line 6 is $0, John’s allowed available basis is $6,000, the amount of 2021 nondeductible traditional IRA contribution. Separately, I blogged about the result if there is a substantial amount on Line 6 (hint: the allowed available basis decreases sharply, see Example 2). 

Unfortunately, I know that at least one tax return preparation software references a worksheet instead of populating the form in the output that the taxpayer sees. The correct information is (apparently) communicated to the IRS through electronic filing, but I wish all software providers simply populated the form to make it easier for review. 

Having successfully completed the first page of the Form 8606, the odds are that page 2 will also be successfully completed. Here’s what it should look like:

The final check on all of this comes from page 1 of Form 1040. If the Form 8606 is not correctly prepared, page 1 of Form 1040 will not correctly reflect the taxation of the Backdoor Roth IRA.

Assuming the taxpayer completed a 2021 Backdoor Roth IRA as John Smith did, page 1 of Form 1040 should look like this:

The key lines are Line 4a and Line 4b. Line 4a will simply be the sum of all Box 1’s from Forms 1099-R. In John’s case, that is $6,001. Line 4b is where the confusion comes. If the Form 8606 is properly prepared, the correct amount from Line 18 of Form 8606 should be the taxable amount reported on Line 4b of Form 8606. 

Fixing Backdoor Roth IRA Errors

Errors in previously filed tax returns can be fixed! I previously blogged about amending previously filed tax returns in cases where a Backdoor Roth IRA has been mistakenly reported. 

2023 Tax Season Backdoor Roth IRA Tax Return Reporting

Watch me discuss Backdoor Roth IRA tax return reporting.

Conclusion

Getting Backdoor Roth IRA tax return reporting is the last vital step in successfully executing a Backdoor Roth IRA. While it is not a simple exercise, it can be navigated with educational resources such as this blog post.

While tax return preparation software is great, it does not replace a taxpayer’s own judgment. Ultimately it is up to the taxpayer to ensure that the tax return properly reports the Backdoor Roth IRA. In many cases it will be wise to use a professional tax return preparer to prepare a tax return if the taxpayer has done a Backdoor Roth IRA.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on Twitter: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

Sean on the Stacking Benjamins Podcast

I talk tax with Joe Saul-Sehy on today’s episode of the Stacking Benjamins podcast. Available on YouTube and all major podcast players. https://www.stackingbenjamins.com/stories-from-our-stackers-1158/

This post, podcast, and video are for entertainment and educational purposes only. They do not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

Sean Launches YouTube Channel

Enjoy videos on my brand new YouTube Channel. The channel will focus on tax and personal finance topics. I have ten tax videos up there to watch. My goal is to post a new tax or personal finance video every Saturday morning at 7AM Pacific.

Highlights include an update on 2022 Backdoor Roth IRAs, news on 72(t) payments, and one way to use tax planning to fight inflation.

Videos will usually be anywhere from 2 to 5 minutes.

I appreciate your viewing and liking my videos. Please subscribe to my channel.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on Twitter: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post, and all videos, text, and comments on my YouTube channel, are for entertainment and educational purposes only. They do not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

What are Section 199A Dividends?

Did you receive a Form 1099-DIV which lists an amount in Box 5 “Section 199A dividends”? If so, you might be asking, what the heck are Section 199A dividends? 

You probably never came across the term “Section 199A dividends” in high school algebra. That’s okay. Below I discuss what a Section 199A dividend is and how to report it on your tax return. 

Watch me discuss how Section 199A Dividends are reported on tax returns.

Who Pays Section 199A Dividends?

Real estate investment trusts (“REITs”) pay Section 199A dividends. REITs are a special type of business entity. A REIT owns almost entirely real estate. Many office buildings, hotels, hospitals, malls, and apartment buildings are owned by REITs. Investors can own the stock of a single REIT, or they can own mutual funds or ETFs that are partly or entirely composed of REIT stock. For example, there are some REITs in the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund (VTSAX). 

REITs are advantageous from a tax perspective. In exchange for paying 90 plus percent of its income out to investors as dividends, the REIT itself does not pay federal corporate income taxes. This results in REITs often paying higher dividends than companies in other industries. The dividends paid by the REIT are Section 199A dividends.

I discuss the Section 199A dividends paid by VTSAX in this video.

What is the Tax Benefit of a Section 199A Dividend?

A Section 199A dividend qualifies for the Section 199A qualified business income deduction. This is also referred to as the QBI deduction. The qualified business income deduction is a 20 percent federal income tax deduction. 

Here is an example of how the tax deduction works for Section 199A dividends.

Catherine owns shares of ABC REIT Mutual Fund. The mutual fund pays her $1,000.00 of dividends, all of which are Section 199A dividends reported to her in both Box 1a and Box 5 of Form 1099-DIV. She gets a $200 qualified business income deduction on her federal tax return (20 percent of $1,000.00) because of the $1,000.00 of Section 199A dividend.

There are several things to keep in mind when considering Section 199A dividends:

  1. Section 199A dividends are a slice of the pie of dividends. The full pie of dividends, “total ordinary dividends,” is reported in Box 1a of Form 1099-DIV. Since Box 1a reports all of the dividends, Box 5 must be equal to or less than Box 1a.
  1. There is no income limit (taxable income, MAGI, or otherwise) on the ability to claim the Section 199A qualified business income deduction for Section 199A dividends. The QBI deduction for self-employment income is generally subject to taxable income limitations on the ability to claim the deduction. Not so with the Section 199A dividends. Taxpayers can claim the QBI deduction for Section 199A dividends regardless of their level of income.
  1. Taxpayers get the Section 199A QBI deduction regardless of whether they claim the standard deduction or itemized deductions. 
  1. There is no requirement to be engaged in a qualified trade or business to claim the QBI deduction for Section 199A dividends. 
  1. The QBI deduction does not reduce adjusted gross income. Thus, it does not help a taxpayer qualify for many tax benefits, such as the ability to make an annual contribution to a Roth IRA. 
  1. Section 199A dividends are not qualified dividends (which are reported in Box 1b of Form 1099-DIV). They are taxed as ordinary income subject to the taxpayer’s ordinary income tax rates. They do not qualify for the preferred federal income tax rates for qualified dividends. 

Where Do I Report a Section 199A Dividend on My Tax Return?

Section 199A dividends create tax return reporting in three prominent places on a federal income tax return.

First, Form 1099-DIV Box 1a total ordinary dividends are reported on Form 1040 Line 3b. As Section 199A dividends are a component of Box 1a total ordinary dividends, they are thus reported on the Form 1040 on Line 3b. Section 199A dividends are not reported on Line 3a of Form 1040 because Section 199A dividends are not qualified dividends. 

Second, Section 199A dividends are reported on either Line 6 of Form 8995 or Line 28 of Form 8995-A. In most cases, taxpayers will file the simpler Form 8995 to report qualified business income and Section 199A dividends. By reporting Section 199A dividends on one of those lines most tax return preparation software should flow the dividends through the rest of the form as appropriate (but it never hurts to double check).

Third, the QBI deduction, computed on either Form 8995 or Form 8995-A, is claimed on Line 13 of Form 1040. 

Tax return software varies. Hopefully, by entering the Form 1099-DIV in full in the software’s Form 1099-DIV input form, all of the above will be generated. Ultimately, it is up to the taxpayer to review the return to ensure that the information has been properly input and properly reported on the tax return.

Conclusion 

Section 199A dividends create a taxpayer favorable federal income tax deduction. They are reported in Box 5 of Form 1099-DIV and should be reported on a taxpayer’s federal income tax return. 

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on X at @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, legal, investment, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

72(t) Series of Substantially Equal Periodic Payments Update

The IRS and Treasury have recently issued two updates to the rules for payments which avoid the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty from retirement accounts. These payments are referred to as a series of substantially equal periodic payments, SEPP, or 72(t) payments. This post discusses the updated rules. 

72(t) Payments

Tax advantaged retirement accounts are fantastic. Who doesn’t love 401(k)s, IRAs, Roth IRAs, and the like?

However, investing through a tax advantaged account can have drawbacks. One big drawback is that taxable amounts withdrawn from a tax advantaged retirement account prior to the account owner turning age 59 ½ are generally subject to a 10 percent early withdrawal penalty. My home state of California adds a 2.5 percent early withdrawal penalty. 

There are some exceptions to this penalty. One of them is taking 72(t) payments. The idea is that if the taxpayer takes a “series of substantially equal periodic payments” they can avoid the penalty. 

72(t) payments must be taken annually. Further, they must last for the longer of (a) 5 years or (b) the time until the taxpayer turns age 59 ½. This creates years of locked-in taxable income. 

There are three methods that can be used to compute the amount of the annual 72(t) payments. These methods compute an annual distribution amount generally keyed off three numbers: the balance in the relevant retirement account, the interest rate, and the table factor provided by the IRS. The factor is greater the younger the account owner is. The greater the factor, the less the account owner can withdraw from a retirement account in a 72(t) payment.

New 72(t) Payment Interest Rates

In January 2022, the IRS and Treasury issued Notice 2022-6. Hat tip to Ed Zollars for the alert. This notice provides some new 72(t) rules. The biggest, and most welcome, change is a new rule for determining the interest rate.

Previously, the rule had been that 72(t) payments were keyed off 120 percent of the mid-term applicable federal rate (“AFR”). The IRS publishes this rate every month. In recent years, that has been somewhat problematic, as interest rates have been historically low. For example, in September 2020, the mid-term AFR was just 0.42 percent. This made relying on a 72(t) payment somewhat perilous. How much juice can be squeezed from a large retirement account if the interest rate is just 0.42 percent?

Here is what a $1M traditional IRA could produce, under the fixed amortization method, in terms of an annual payment for a 53 year old starting a 72(t) payment if the interest rate is just 0.42 percent:

120% of Sept 2020 MidTerm AFR0.42%
Single Life Expectancy Years at Age 5333.4
Account Balance$1,000,000.00
Annual Payment$32,151.93

Notice 2022-6 makes a very significant change. It now allows taxpayers to pick the greater of (i) up to 5 percent or (ii) up to 120 percent of mid-term AFR. That one change makes a 72(t) payment a much more attractive option, since periods of low interest rates do not as adversely affect the calculation. 

Here is what a $1M traditional IRA could produce, under the fixed amortization method, in terms of an annual payment for a 53 year old starting a 72(t) payment if the interest rate is 5 percent:

5% Interest Rate5.00%
Single Life Expectancy Years at Age 5333.4
Account Balance$1,000,000.00
Annual Payment$62,189.80

The new rule provides a 5 percent interest rate floor for those using the fixed amortization method and the fixed annuitization method to compute a 72(t) payment. Using a 5 percent interest rate under the fixed amortization method is generally going to produce a greater payment amount than using the required minimum distribution method for 72(t) payments. 

The interest rate change provides taxpayers with much more flexibility with 72(t) payments, and a greater ability to extract more money penalty free prior to age 59 ½. Taxpayers already have the ability to “right-size” the traditional IRA out of which to take a 72(t) payment to help the numbers work out. In recent years, what has been much less flexible has been the interest rate. Under these new rules, taxpayers always have the ability to select anywhere from just above 0% to 5% regardless of what 120 percent of mid-term AFR is. 

Watch me discuss the update to 72(t) payment interest rates.

New Tables

A second new development is that the IRS and Treasury have issued new life expectancy tables for required minimum distributions (“RMDs”) and 72(t) payments. Most of the new tables are found at Treasury Regulation Section 1.401(a)(9)-9, though one new table is found at the end of Notice 2022-6. 

These tables reflect increasing life expectancies. As a result, they reduce the amount of RMDs, as the factors used to compute RMDs are greater as life expectancy increases. 

From a 72(t) payment perspective, this development is a minor taxpayer unfavorable development. Long life expectancies in the tables means the tables slightly reduce the amount of juice that can be squeezed out of any particular retirement account.

This said, the downside to 72(t) payments coming from increasing life expectancy on the tables is more than overcome by the ability to always use an interest rate of up to 5 percent. These two developments in total are a great net win for taxpayers looking to use 72(t) payments during retirement. 

Use of 72(t) Payments

Traditionally, I have viewed 72(t) payments as a life raft rather than as a desirable planning tool for those retiring prior to their 59 ½th birthday. Particularly for those in the FI community, my view has been that it is better to spend down taxable assets and even dip into Roth basis rather than employ a 72(t) payment plan. 

These developments shift my view a bit. Yes, I still view 72(t) payments as a life raft. Now it is an upgraded life raft with a small flatscreen TV and mini-fridge. 😉

As a practical matter, some will get to retirement prior to age 59 ½ with little in taxable and Roth accounts, and the vast majority of their financial wealth in traditional retirement accounts. Notice 2022-6 just made their situation much better and much more flexible. Getting to retirement at a time of very low interest rates does not necessarily hamstring their retirement plans given that they will always have at least a 5 percent interest rate to use in calculating their 72(t) payments. 

72(t) Payments and Roth IRAs

As Roth accounts grow in value, there will be at least some thought of marrying Roth IRAs with 72(t) payments. 

At least initially, Roth IRAs have no need for 72(t) payments. Those retired prior to age 59 ½ can withdraw previous Roth contributions and Roth conversions aged at least 5 years at any time tax and penalty free for any reason. So off the bat, no particular issue, as nonqualified distributions will start-off as being tax and penalty free.

Only after all Roth contributions have been withdrawn are Roth conversions withdrawn, and they are withdrawn first-in, first-out. Only after all Roth conversions are withdrawn does a taxpayer withdraw Roth earnings.  

For most, the odds of withdrawing (i) Roth conversions that are less than five years old, and then (ii) Roth earnings prior to age 59 ½ are slim. But, there could some who love Roths so much they largely or entirely eschew traditional retirement account contributions. One could imagine an early retiree with only Roth IRAs. 

Being “Roth only” prior to age 59 ½ could present problems if contributions and conversions at least 5 years old have been fully depleted. Taxpayers left with withdrawing conversions less than 5 years old or earnings in a nonqualified distribution might opt to establish a 72(t) payment plan for their Roth IRA. Such a 72(t) payment plan could avoid the 10 percent penalty on the withdrawn amounts attributable insufficiently aged conversions or Roth earnings. Note, however, that Roth earnings withdrawn in a nonqualified distribution are subject to ordinary income tax, regardless of whether they are part of a 72(t) payment plan. 

See Treasury Regulation Section 1.408A-6 Q&A 5 providing that Roth IRA distributions can be subject to both the 72(t) early withdrawal penalty and the exceptions to the 72(t) penalty. The exceptions include a 72(t) payment plan. 

Additional Resource

Ed Zollars has an excellent post on the updated IRS rules for 72(t) payments here.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on Twitter: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters.Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

2022 Backdoor Roth IRA

The Backdoor Roth IRA lives! The proposal to repeal the Backdoor Roth IRA as of January 1, 2022 will not be enacted in 2021, as it is now abundantly clear that the Build Back Better legislative program will not be enacted anytime soon. 

But could the proposal come back in 2022? How does one do financial planning in this regard in this climate of uncertainty?

Below I discuss how I approach the issue of whether one should execute a Backdoor Roth IRA in early 2022. What follows is my opinion of the possibilities that could play out. They are simply one person’s opinion in the face of a somewhat uncertain situation. 

Nothing below is tax advice for any individual taxpayer to rely upon. 

Update February 5, 2022: Watch my updated assessment of the 2022 Backdoor Roth IRA landscape on YouTube.

Planning for Uncertainty

To tackle the issue of whether to execute a Backdoor Roth IRA in early 2022, I believe it is best to think of a hypothetical example and then consider all of the (currently known) possibilities in terms of law changes and their probabilities of occuring. So here’s a hypothetical example:

Single Nurse is 35 years old, single, and makes $170,000 at her W-2 job in 2022. She is covered by a 401(k) at work. Her 2022 modified adjusted gross income (“MAGI”) makes her ineligible to make an annual contribution to a Roth IRA. On January 1, 2022, Single Nurse contributes $6,000 to a traditional IRA. On January 5, 2022, Single Nurse converts the entire balance in her traditional IRA, $6,000.23, to a Roth IRA. Assuming Single Nurse takes no other action, she will have $0 in all traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and SIMPLE IRAs on December 31, 2022. 

Will Single Nurse be happy she executed a Backdoor Roth IRA early in 2022?

Let’s analyze the various possibilities in terms of new laws during 2022 and how they could impact Single Nurse’s 2022 Backdoor Roth IRA. Many thanks to Pixabay.com for the emoji reaction pictures and the featured image!

Note that Possible Outcomes #3 through #6 include the small possibility that Congress enacts a repeal of the Backdoor Roth IRA separate from the Build Back Better program.

Possible Outcome #1: No Portion of Build Back Better is Enacted in 2022

Sean’s Estimated Probability of Occurring: 70%

Under this outcome, Single Nurse is quite pleased with her 2022 Backdoor Roth IRA. She’s happy she executed it, even though she could have done it much later in the year.

Single Nurse’s reaction:


Possible Outcome #2: A New Version of Build Back Better is Enacted in 2022 Which Does Not Repeal the Backdoor Roth IRA

Sean’s Estimated Probability: 15%

Single Nurse is again quite pleased with her 2022 Backdoor Roth IRA in January, even though she could have waited. 

Single Nurse’s reaction:


Possible Outcome #3: A New Version of Build Back Better is Enacted in 2022 Which Repeals the Backdoor Roth IRA Effective January 1, 2023

Sean’s Estimated Probability: 10%

Single Nurse is again quite pleased with her 2022 Backdoor Roth IRA in January, though she’ll miss the Backdoor Roth IRA in 2023. 

If Congress does enact legislation in 2022 to repeal the Backdoor Roth IRA, I agree with Steven Rosenthal that the most likely effective date is January 1, 2023, which would be the easiest to implement. Changing tax laws during a year creates needless complexity and confusion, and thus I believe a January 1, 2023 effective date is the most likely effective date. 

Single Nurse’s reaction:


Possible Outcome #4: A New Version of Build Back Better is Enacted in 2022 Which Repeals the Backdoor Roth IRA Effective On the Date of Enactment

Sean’s Estimated Probability: 3%

Single Nurse breathes a huge sigh of relief! If she had waited until later in 2022 to execute her 2022 Backdoor Roth IRA, she would not have been able to. She got her 2022 Backdoor Roth IRA in under the wire, and is very happy she executed the Backdoor Roth IRA early in January. 

Single Nurse’s reaction:

Possible Outcome #5: A New Version of Build Back Better is Enacted in 2022 Which Repeals the Backdoor Roth IRA Effective January 1, 2022 and the IRS Treats an Early 2022 Backdoor Roth IRA as a Correctable Excess Contribution to a Roth IRA

Sean’s Estimated Probability: 1.6%

This is where it gets really interesting. First of all, a law retroactively repealing a tax law benefit would likely face some sort of legal challenge were to be enforced retroactively. For now, I will put an analysis of that outcome to the side. 

How would the IRS enforce a repeal of the Backdoor Roth IRA as applied to Backdoor Roth IRAs executed prior to the law change but after a January 1, 2022 effective date? Single Nurse’s Backdoor Roth IRA is both post-effective date and prior to the enactment of the law change. 

This situation would require an administrative transition rule from the IRS and Treasury. I believe the only feasible transition rule would be for the IRS to treat any pre-enactment/post-effective date 2022 Backdoor Roth IRA as an excess contribution to a Roth IRA. Under the excess contribution rules, excess contributions are generally correctable.

This treatment would give Single Nurse three potential courses of action:

  1. Withdraw the $6,000 and the growth on the $6,000 from the Roth IRA (a corrective distribution) by October 16, 2023.* Any growth on the $6,000 originally contributed is taxable to Single Nurse as ordinary income in 2022; or
  2. Recharacterize the $6,000 and the growth on the $6,000 as a traditional IRA by October 16, 2023. This will result in Single Nurse having a traditional IRA with a basis of $6,000; or,
  3. If neither Option 1 or Option 2 is timely executed by October 16, 2023, Single Nurse owes a six percent penalty on the $6,000 excess contribution ($360) and will owe an additional six percent penalty for every additional year the $6,000 Roth contribution (but not the earnings) is not withdrawn from the Roth IRA. 

I do not see another administratively feasible alternative for the IRS to enforce a retroactive repeal of the Backdoor Roth IRA in 2022. 

I believe the IRS and Treasury would also apply this treatment (or a similar treatment) to any split-year Backdoor Roth IRAs completed in 2022 for the 2021 tax year.

*Update 1/6/2022: Upon further reflection, I believe remedial action to correct an excess Roth IRA contribution in this hypothetical situation can occur by the extended tax return due date. See the bottom of page 42 of IRS Publication 590-A. An earlier version of this post used April 15, 2023 as the deadline date for all three remedial courses of action.

This outcome is not all that bad for Single Nurse. An opportunity taken away for sure, but the “downside” consequences are not all that deleterious. The downside appears limited to ordinary income tax on a few months of growth on $6,000. 

Single Nurse’s reaction:

Possible Outcome #6: A New Version of Build Back Better is Enacted in 2022 Which Repeals the Backdoor Roth IRA Effective January 1, 2022 and the IRS Treats Early 2022 Backdoor Roth IRAs in a Different Manner

Sean’s Estimated Probability: 0.4%

This outcome accounts for the unknown. The IRS and Treasury might take a different approach than the one I outline in Possible Outcome #5. To my mind, the absolute worst outcome would be the six percent penalty tax on an excess contribution. Even then, it is difficult to imagine a scenario where the IRS would not allow remedial action to avoid the six percent penalty.

Single Nurse’s reaction:

Single Nurse’s Assessment

Single Nurse will need to make a subjective assessment of the possibilities and the risks. She is likely to assign somewhat different probabilities to the various possible outcomes than I do. Further, she will have to determine how much she values the possible benefit of an early Backdoor Roth IRA (Possible Outcome #4 in particular, and Possible Outcomes #1 through #3) versus the costs of an early Backdoor Roth IRA (Possible Outcomes #5 and 6). 

My own assessment is that Single Nurse is more likely to benefit from executing an early Backdoor Roth IRA than she is to be (slightly) harmed by it, because I believe that Possible Outcome #4 is more likely than Possible Outcomes #5 and #6. 

Conclusion

Of course, none of the above is advice for any particular taxpayer. Rather, it serves to illustrate how one financial planner would go about systematically assessing the probabilities, risks, and rewards associated with an early 2022 Backdoor Roth IRA.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on Twitter: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here. 

The End of the End of the Backdoor Roth IRA?

Update as of December 20, 2021: I originally posted this article on Saturday morning, December 18th. On Sunday, developments occurred which called into question the use of a question mark in the article’s title.

Senator Joe Manchin appeared on Fox News Sunday and very publicly indicated he is a No on Build Back Better. He followed that with a written statement outlining his opposition to Build Back Better. The White House issued a statement in response to Senator Manchin.

A fair assessment indicates the parties are not at all close on this one. This is not a situation where Senator Manchin is bargaining to get A, B, and C into the bill and the White House is hoping to only have to give B and C. While anything is possible with tax legislation, it is quite difficult to argue that the Build Back Better program (which includes Backdoor Roth IRA repeal) has a realistic possibility of passage in this Congress in anything resembling its current form.

Update February 5, 2022: Watch my updated assessment of the lay of the land on 2022 Backdoor Roth IRAs.

Below is the original post posted on December 18, 2021.

There’s an early Christmas present for tax efficient investors. The proposal to end the Backdoor Roth IRA is on life support, and as of now (December 18, 2021) it appears that even if the proposal passes, it will not pass until 2022 at the earliest.

Latest Developments

The White House has now issued a written statement that the so-called Build Back Better program will not be signed into law this year. The proposal to repeal the Backdoor Roth IRA is one of many tax proposals contained within the overall Build Back Better legislative program. As this Deloitte write-up discusses, it is clear the Senate will not pass the legislation any time in the near-term. Thus, for the time being, the Backdoor Roth IRA is in the clear. 

Prospects for 2022

Update December 28, 2021: Read my assessment of 2022 Backdoor Roth IRAs.

There is a reason the Build Back Better program will not be enacted during 2021: it’s not broadly popular. This is reflected in the current opposition of all 50 Senate Republicans and Democrat Senator Joe Manchin. Further, it is not at all clear that Democrat Senator Kyrsten Sinema will ultimately support Build Back Better. 

If the Build Back Better program were to become popular, the dynamics in the U.S. Senate would likely change. But one must ask: is there something that could occur in early 2022 that would make the legislation popular then when it was not popular in late 2021? 

Another issue the legislation has is the unlikelihood of any potential tax increase passing during an election year. New tax laws have proponents and opponents: in recent years Congress has hesitated to create opponents during election years by enacting significant tax legislation. 

What If?

What if the legislation is enacted in early 2022? What happens to Backdoor Roth IRAs? That is highly, highly speculative. My guess is that if the legislation (at that point) bans Backdoor Roth IRAs, either (i) Backdoor Roth IRAs will be prohibited as of January 1, 2023 (instead of January 1, 2022 in the current legislation) or (ii) prohibited as of the enactment of the law. 

But all sorts of alternative possibilities exist. A much smaller version of the Build Back Better program could be enacted, and that version could omit the Backdoor Roth IRA repeal. Or there will be no legislation enacted at all. 

Why Are We Here?

Is the Backdoor Roth IRA gimmicky? Absolutely it is!

But there is a bigger issue. Why the heck is there any income limitation on the ability to make a $6,000 annual contribution to a Roth IRA? Consider these two examples.

Wealthy Investor controls a large public company and is known for his ability to earn good investment returns. He is worth billions of dollars and is 80 years old. He can direct the large public company to offer a Roth 401(k), and on January 1st of 2022 he can have payroll issued to him, of which he can put $27,000 into his Roth 401(k). 

Single Nurse, age 35, is a nurse and earns $170,000 from her W-2 job. Her employer offers a traditional 401(k) but no Roth 401(k). Single Nurse earns too much (due to the Roth IRA modified adjusted gross income limit) to make an annual $6,000 contribution to a Roth IRA. As a result, Single Nurse’s annual Roth contributions are limited to $0.

Wealthy Investor can contribute $27,000 to a Roth 401(k) but Single Nurse can’t contribute $6,000 to a Roth IRA?

To borrow an exasperated quote from Cosmo Kramer, “What’s going on!!!”

The Backdoor Roth IRA solves this problem for Single Nurse and many other Americans. This workaround does not work for all Americans, as I have previously written. 

The simplest solution is to eliminate the modified adjusted gross income limit for all Roth IRA contributions. So some very wealthy Americans will get a few thousand dollars into Roth IRAs every year. Is this a horribly worrisome outcome considering many very wealthy Americans already have access to much greater workplace retirement plan contributions with absolutely no income limitation?

Once the income limit on the ability to make a Roth IRA contribution is repealed, there will be no need for Backdoor Roth IRAs. 

Conclusion

The only constant in the tax world is change. We shall see what the future holds for the Backdoor Roth IRA, but the coast appears to be clear for the rest of the year. Stay tuned!

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on Twitter: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.

FI Tax Guy Featured on the Optimal Finance Daily Podcast

Today and tomorrow my year-end tax planning post will be featured on the Optimal Finance Daily podcast.

Listen to today’s episode on podcast players and here.

Read my year-end tax planning blog post here.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on Twitter: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here. 

Sean Talks Tax with DocG

Listen to my discussion with DocG on the latest episode of the Earn and Invest podcast. Available on all major podcast players and at this link: https://www.earnandinvest.com/episodes/five-tax-questions-you-must-ask

FI Tax Guy can be your financial advisor! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on Twitter: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here. 

Tax Planning for Inflation

In recent years, inflation existed but was not significant. Significant inflation was associated with wide lapels and eight-track tapes and thought to be left behind in the late 1970s and early 1980s.

But, sure enough, significant inflation is back. Inflation is 6.2 percent for the 12 months ending October 2021.  

Inflation has a tax angle. How does one use tax planning to minimize the impact of inflation? In this post, I review the issues associated with inflation and tactics to consider if one is concerned about inflation.

Inflation: The Tax Problem

Inflation increases the nominal (i.e., stated) value of assets without a corresponding increase in the real value of the asset. Here is an example:

Larry buys $100,000 worth of XYZ Mutual Fund on January 1, 2022. During the year 2022, there is 10 percent inflation. On January 1, 2023, the XYZ Mutual Fund is worth $110,000. Inflation-adjusted, the position has the same real value as it did when Larry purchased it. However, were Larry to sell the entire position, he would trigger a $10,000 capital gain ($110,000 sales price less $100,000 tax basis), which would be taxable to him. 

Hopefully you see the problem: Larry has not experienced a real increase in wealth. Larry’s taxable “gain” is not a gain. Rather, it is simply inflation! Larry will pay tax on inflation if he sells the asset. Ouch!

While inflation increases the nominal value of assets, there is no inflation adjustment to tax basis! Thus, inflation creates artificial gains subject to income tax. 

There are other tax problems with inflation. Inflation artificially increases amounts received as wages, self-employment income, interest, dividends, and retirement plan distributions. Those artificial increases are not real increases in income (as they do not represent increases in value) but they are subject to income tax as though they were real increases in income.

The tax law does provide some remedy to address the problem of taxing inflation. The IRS provides inflation adjustments to increase the size of progressive tax brackets. In addition, the standard deduction is adjusted annually for inflation. Recently the IRS released the inflation adjustments for 2022.  

IRS inflation adjustments are helpful, but they do not excuse inflation from taxation. Rather, they only soften the blow. Thus, they are not a full cure for the tax problems caused by inflation. 

Inflation and Traditional Retirement Accounts

Inflation is detrimental to traditional retirement accounts such as pre-tax 401(k)s and IRAs. Holding assets inside a traditional retirement account subjects the taxpayer to income tax on the growth in the assets caused by inflation.

Inflation artificially increases amounts in these accounts that will ultimately be subject to taxation. Inflation can also limit the opportunity to do Roth conversions in early retirement. Greater balances to convert from traditional to Roth accounts and increased dividend, capital gain, and interest income triggered by inflation makes early retiree Roth conversion planning more challenging. 

Inflation and Real Estate

There are several tax benefits of rental real estate. One of the main benefits is depreciation. For residential real estate, the depreciable basis is deducted in a straight-line over 27.5 years. For example, if the depreciable basis of a rental condo is $275,000, the annual depreciation tax deduction (for 27.5 years) is $10,000 (computed as $275,000 divided by 27.5). That number rarely changes, as most of the depreciable basis is determined at the time the property is purchased or constructed. 

Over time, inflation erodes the value of depreciation deductions. Inflation generally increases rental income, but the depreciation deduction stays flat nominally and decreases in real value. Increasing inflation reduces the tax benefits provided by rental real estate. 

Planning Techniques

There are planning techniques that can protect taxpayers against the tax threat posed by inflation. 

Roth Contributions and Conversions

Inflation is yet another tax villain the Roth can slay. Tax free growth inside a Roth account avoids the tax on inflation. 

Once inside a Roth, concerns about inflation increasing taxes generally vanish. Properly planned, Roths provide tax free growth and tax free withdrawals. Thus, Roths effectively eliminate the concern about paying tax on inflation. 

For those thinking of Roth conversions, inflation concerns point to accelerating Roth conversions. The sooner amounts inside traditional retirement accounts are converted to Roth accounts, the less exposure the amounts have to inflation taxes. 

Roth contributions and conversions provide tax insurance against the threat of inflation. For those very concerned about inflation, this consideration moves the needle toward the Roth in the ongoing Roth versus traditional debate. 

Watch me discuss using Roth accounts to help manage an investor’s exposure to inflation.

Health Savings Accounts

A Health Savings Account, like its Roth IRA cousin, offers tax free growth. HSAs also protect against taxes on inflation. Inflation is another argument to take advantage of an HSA. 

Basis Step Up Planning

There is another tax planning opportunity that can wipe away the taxes owed on years of inflation: the basis step up at death. At death, heirs receive a basis in inherited taxable assets which is usually the fair market value of the assets on the date of death. For taxable assets, death provides an opportunity to escape the tax on inflation.

It is important to note that traditional retirement accounts do not receive a basis step up. Inflation inside a traditional retirement account will eventually be subject to tax (either to the original owner or to a beneficiary after the original owner’s death). 

During one’s lifetime, there is the tax gain harvesting opportunity to step up basis and reduce inflation taxes. The tactic is to sell and repurchase an investment with a built-in gain at a time when the investor does not pay federal income tax on the capital gain. If one can keep their marginal federal income tax rate in the 12% or lower marginal tax bracket, they can pay a 0% federal income tax rate on the gain and “reset” the basis to the repurchase price of the sold and then repurchased asset. 

There is a second flavor of tax gain harvesting: triggering a capital gain (at an advantageous time from a tax perspective) by selling an asset and reinvesting the proceeds in a more desirable asset (essentially, investment reallocation). 

One inflation consideration with respect to tax gain harvesting: as inflation increases interest and dividends, there will be less room inside the 12 percent taxable income bracket to create capital gains that are federal income tax free.

Conclusion

Inflation is yet another tax planning consideration. As we are now in a period of significant inflation, taxpayers and advisors will need to weigh inflation’s potential impact on tax strategies. 

None of the above is advice for any particular taxpayer. Hopefully it provides some educational background to help assess the tax impact of inflation and consider tactical responses to inflation.

FI Tax Guy can be your financial planner! Find out more by visiting mullaneyfinancial.com

Follow me on Twitter: @SeanMoneyandTax

This post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. It does not constitute accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Please consult with your advisor(s) regarding your personal accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax matters. Please also refer to the Disclaimer & Warning section found here.