October 2018 – The FI Tax Guy

Introduction

Tax is a crucial consideration for those with small businesses and side hustles. A new tax provision, Section 199A, passed as part of Tax Reform in December 2017, gives many small business owners and side hustlers a deduction determined with respect to their “qualified business income” (or “QBI”).

So what’s going on? Why would you get a tax deduction for a certain type of income? The short answer is that the Section 199A deduction was needed to help level the playing field for small businesses (especially manufacturers) vis-à-vis large corporations. Tax Reform cut taxes for corporations (generally from 35 percent to 21 percent). To keep small businesses, many of which are taxed on individual tax returns at federal rates up to 37 percent, competitive with larger corporations, Congress enacted a partial deduction for qualified business income. The deduction has the effect of lowering the federal income tax rate on that income.

The QBI deduction also applies to so-called Section 199A dividends. Please see the discussion further below regarding Section 199A dividends.

Do I Qualify for the Section 199A Deduction?

The bad news is that, even for a tax rule, Section 199A is incredibly complex. The much better news is that most of that complexity applies to about 10 percent or less of taxpayers. For 90 plus percent of taxpayers, it isn’t too complicated!

To figure out if it is going to be complicated for you, ask yourself one question (all amounts as applicable for 2021):

Is my taxable income $164,900 or less?

If you’re married filing a joint tax return (“MFJ”), change the question to

Is my taxable income $329,800 or less?

For 2020, apply the above questions with $163,300 for single taxpayers and heads of household, and $326,600 for MFJ taxpayers. For 2021, married filing separate taxpayers use $164,925 as their number.

Remember, the key number is taxable income. Taxable income is your adjusted gross income less your standard deduction ($12,550 in 2021 for singles, $18,800 for heads of householder, and $25,100 for MFJ) or your itemized deductions. So if you take the standard deduction, you’re looking at adjusted gross income of $177,450 for singles, $183,725 for heads of household, and $354,900 for MFJ filers. Those are high thresholds for most Americans and for most of those seeking financial independence).

Section 199A Basic Calculation

If you answered Yes to your bolded question, your Section 199A deduction is computed based on a relatively simple (for tax) calculation. Your Section 199A deduction is the lesser of

20 percent of your taxable income less your “net capital gain” which is generally your capital gains plus your qualified dividend income (“QDI”) or
20 percent of your QBI.

Here are two examples to illustrate the calculation (all examples avoid discussing self-employment tax for ease of illustration):

Example 1: Phil has $100,000 of W-2 wage income, $1,000 of QDI from mutual funds owned in taxable accounts, makes $10,000 from a trade or business side hustle reported on Schedule C, and claims the standard deduction on his tax return. Phil’s Section 199A deduction is the lesser of

20% of Phil’s taxable income less net capital gain ($100,000 of wages, plus $1,000 QDI plus $10,000 of QBI less $12,000 standard deduction less $1,000 “net capital gain” – in this case, his QDI – equals $98,000. $98,000 X 20% = $19,600) or
20% of Phil’s QBI ($10,000 X 20% = $2,000).

Thus, Phil’s Section 199A deduction is $2,000, fully 20 percent of his side hustle income.

Example 2: Mary owns a sole proprietorship engaged in a domestic trade or business which earned $100,000 this year reported on Schedule C. Mary also earned $1,000 of QDI from mutual funds owned in taxable accounts and claims the standard deduction on her tax return. Mary’s Section 199A deduction is the lesser of

20% of her taxable income less net capital gain ($100,000 of Schedule C income plus $1,000 QDI less $12,000 standard deduction less $1,000 “net capital gain” – in this case, her QDI – equals $88,000. $88,000 X 20% = $17,600) or
20% of her QBI ($100,000 X 20% = $20,000).

Thus, Mary’s Section 199A deduction is $17,600, 17.6 percent of her sole proprietorship income.

Section 199A is great news for side hustlers and pretty good news for sole proprietors and other owners of flow-through businesses. Why the slight benefit reduction for our sole proprietor? The answer lies in the benefit of the standard deduction (or itemized deductions, if applicable). Since Mary already had the standard deduction protecting some of her QBI from full taxation, the Section 199A deduction was reduced to account for that benefit.

Note that if Mary had another source of income (other than long-term capital gains or qualified dividend income), such as a Roth conversion amount, or a spouse with income, that income would increase her taxable income limitation and she could qualify for up-to the full 20 percent QDI deduction.

What is QBI?

Now that we have the calculation illustrated, we must ask what is “qualified business income” (“QBI”)? Generally, QBI is domestic income from a trade or business (as defined under normal U.S. tax principles) received by a sole proprietor or by an individual from a “flow-through” business (a partnership, LLC, S-corporation, trust, or estate). Some important considerations:

QBI does not include wage income (W-2 income).
It is important to maintain documentation supporting that the activity is a trade or business.
It is important that the activity not be considered a hobby.
Rental income from the active conduct of a rental real estate trade or business is QBI. Income from the renting out of buildings where the owner is not engaged in a real estate trade or business is not QBI. Real estate may become a hot-spot for disputes between the IRS and taxpayers.

High Income Taxpayers

What if you answered No to your question? If you have QBI, you’re likely to need the assistance of a qualified tax professional. The rules get complicated quickly. For those with taxable income above $164,900 ($329,800 for MFJ, $164,925 for MFS), their Section 199A deduction is subject to a limitation and possibly a second additional limitation, as follows:

For taxpayers over the taxable income thresholds, all QBI is subject to a limitation on the Section 199A deduction based on W-2 wages paid by the business and the unadjusted asset basis in the business. The more of these attributes, the greater the Section 199A deduction. Note that unadjusted asset basis is generally the acquisition cost of property. It includes tangible property (including buildings) but does not include land.
Income from a specified service trade or business suffers an additional limitation. The Section 199A deduction for such income is phased out for taxable incomes between $164,900 and $214,900 ($329,800 and $429,800 for MFJ filers) (using 2021 numbers).

The preamble to the proposed regulations states that a “specified service trade or business” is (1) any trade or business involving the performance of services in the fields of health, law, accounting, actuarial science, performing arts, consulting, athletics, financial services, brokerage services, or any trade or business where the principal asset of such trade or business is the reputation or skill of one or more of its employees or owners, and (2) any trade or business that involves the performance of services that consist of investing and investment management, trading, or dealing in securities . . . partnership interests, or commodities.”

The general idea behind the specified service trade or business is that Congress wanted to prevent high earning doctors, lawyers, accountants, etc., from benefiting from Section 199A. Congress intended for the benefits to generally go to manufacturers. Manufacturers will generally find themselves only subject to the first limitation, and many will have buildings and equipment with tax basis and/or will pay significant W-2 wages to employees and thus will not find the limitation to have much effect.

For those subject to these complex limitations, there can be significant benefits from doing planning and restructuring with the assistance of qualified tax advisors to maximize their Section 199A deduction. Such planning can include planning to increase current year tax deductions (through, for example, increased retirement plan contributions) to reduce taxable income below the relevant testing thresholds.

Section 199A Dividends and Income from Publicly Traded Partnerships

Qualified dividends from real estate investment trusts (“REITs”) (Section 199A dividends) and ordinary income from publicly traded partnerships qualify for the Section 199A deduction. There is no need for the taxpayer to be in a trade or business and there are no limitations based on taxable income. In terms of sheer volume, I expect more returns will claim this Section 199A QBI deduction than the QBI deduction for “normal” qualified business income discussed above.

It is important to note that dividends and other income received in tax advantaged accounts (IRAs, 401(k)s, HSAs, other retirement accounts) does not qualify for the Section 199A deduction.

Tax Reporting

Taxpayers report their QBI deduction on either a Form 8995 or a Form 8995-A (for the 2019 tax year and later). Box 5 of Form 1099-DIV (Section 199A dividends) reports the dividends that qualify for the QBI deduction.

Monthly Archives: October 2018

Section 199A for Beginners